Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jan 5, 4:52 AM
#1

Offline
Jul 2021
685
Shield Hero have a very interesting premise in season 1 part 1. But after the MC got his revenge it went all downhill and became just a generic Isekai Harem.

Now my question is, Will this anime fall into the same trap like Shield Hero? (Any light novel reader want to clarify this.)
Jan 5, 5:07 AM
#2
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Certainly not, because
, but that's not the point, since Shield Hero has always been much more than a revenge story (I read both light novels), so I know what I'm talking about.

However, if someone who watched Shield Hero thought the story was just about revenge and was disappointed to see that the anime was much more than that, I understand the frustration.
Jan 5, 5:28 AM
#3
Offline
Oct 2023
50
Shield Hero fell off hard when Naofumi got his revenge (I think in ep 13) and season 2 was miserable so I hope not
Jan 5, 5:33 AM
#4
Offline
Jan 2025
55
Shield Hero was a disappointment because it lacked any real goal or meaning to the hero's journey after he got his revenge. You can't expect to love the anime if the protagonist doesn't really have any reason to fight other than collecting more girls in his 'zoo'

I haven't read the novel but I believe this anime might be another Mushoku Tensei (minus ecchi?) which means it's going to be great or even peak.

But why is the novel rated 6? Did the story get worse down the line (please don't spoil)?
pelik_luv_animeJan 5, 5:38 AM
Jan 5, 5:46 AM
#5
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to pelik_luv_anime
Shield Hero was a disappointment because it lacked any real goal or meaning to the hero's journey after he got his revenge. You can't expect to love the anime if the protagonist doesn't really have any reason to fight other than collecting more girls in his 'zoo'

I haven't read the novel but I believe this anime might be another Mushoku Tensei (minus ecchi?) which means it's going to be great or even peak.

But why is the novel rated 6? Did the story get worse down the line (please don't spoil)?
@pelik_luv_anime The Yuusha Kei light novel isn't rated on MyAnimeList, you must be referring to the manga, which is bad compared to the light novel.
Regarding the light novel itself, it doesn't seem popular in the West, but in Japan it won an award for promising light novels and came in second in another.

About the story, well, I've never read Mushoku, but Yuusha Kei is quite different because it focuses almost entirely on action, and that's its best quality.
Jan 5, 7:00 AM
#6
Offline
Jan 2021
1071
The chemistry of the characters and dialogues tells me thats gonna most likely happen, just seems very amateurish writing but I’d probably still enjoy it if the animations is this good every episode.
Jan 5, 7:13 AM
#7
Offline
Dec 2022
1116
Shield Hero is literally better than this.
Jan 5, 9:05 AM
#8
Offline
Jul 2024
75
Pablo_Neruda1 said:
Shield Hero is literally better than this.

Ragebait used to be believable...
Jan 5, 9:31 AM
#9
Offline
Jul 2019
15
All aside, imagine watching a single episode and give it a score... I am telling you 8329 users.
Jan 5, 9:36 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to uyuryazar
All aside, imagine watching a single episode and give it a score... I am telling you 8329 users.
@uyuryazar Well, if there's only one episode 1 released, it's obvious that the rating corresponds to that episode.
Come on, it's not that hard to understand 😣

Your logic simply doesn't make sense. Anime are released weekly so that the audience can enjoy them and so that interest continues throughout the season, so giving a rating is only to say how the anime is currently doing.
If you don't like it, the only solution is to tell the anime industry to start releasing complete anime series with all episodes available.
DesmascaradoJan 5, 9:46 AM
Jan 5, 10:23 AM
Offline
Jul 2019
15
Reply to Desmascarado
@uyuryazar Well, if there's only one episode 1 released, it's obvious that the rating corresponds to that episode.
Come on, it's not that hard to understand 😣

Your logic simply doesn't make sense. Anime are released weekly so that the audience can enjoy them and so that interest continues throughout the season, so giving a rating is only to say how the anime is currently doing.
If you don't like it, the only solution is to tell the anime industry to start releasing complete anime series with all episodes available.
@Desmascarado Your logic doesn't make sense because some of these people will drop the series and will never update their scores.

If you take a look long running series like One Piece or Naruto Shippuuden, you will see there are positive and negative reviews that are made early as 2008-2012, some with 50 episodes in, some 100-200 episodes in, and if you check those, you will see most of them pretty much stopped watching after that. And they all have effect on the total score. There is your proof that giving it a early rating is NOT to say how the anime is currently doing because these people don't have any idea how it went after that. This isn't IMDB that you can score each episode seperately.

And it is naive you think these people will keep update their thoughts and scores after each episode to show how the anime is currently doing.
Jan 5, 11:19 AM
Offline
Jun 2022
21
hopefully not this one seems promising
Jan 5, 12:07 PM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to uyuryazar
@Desmascarado Your logic doesn't make sense because some of these people will drop the series and will never update their scores.

If you take a look long running series like One Piece or Naruto Shippuuden, you will see there are positive and negative reviews that are made early as 2008-2012, some with 50 episodes in, some 100-200 episodes in, and if you check those, you will see most of them pretty much stopped watching after that. And they all have effect on the total score. There is your proof that giving it a early rating is NOT to say how the anime is currently doing because these people don't have any idea how it went after that. This isn't IMDB that you can score each episode seperately.

And it is naive you think these people will keep update their thoughts and scores after each episode to show how the anime is currently doing.
@uyuryazar No, if an anime didn't generate enough interest for a particular person to watch it to the end, that person's rating is valid because the anime failed to hold their attention.

"I myself drop anime that I give a good rating to because the anime was good, I just didn't like it."

In other words, if a certain person watches an anime to the end and gives it a 1/10, it means that for that person the anime was awful, but at least it held their attention.
Therefore, the ratings of people who dropped it are valid and, moreover, important for us to know if the anime is good/bad, interesting/uninteresting.

I also have my criticisms of the MyAnimeList rating system, but complaints like yours are factually wrong.
Jan 5, 2:12 PM
Offline
Jul 2019
15
Reply to Desmascarado
@uyuryazar No, if an anime didn't generate enough interest for a particular person to watch it to the end, that person's rating is valid because the anime failed to hold their attention.

"I myself drop anime that I give a good rating to because the anime was good, I just didn't like it."

In other words, if a certain person watches an anime to the end and gives it a 1/10, it means that for that person the anime was awful, but at least it held their attention.
Therefore, the ratings of people who dropped it are valid and, moreover, important for us to know if the anime is good/bad, interesting/uninteresting.

I also have my criticisms of the MyAnimeList rating system, but complaints like yours are factually wrong.
@Desmascarado Yours are factually wrong. In fact, you prove yourself wrong in the same sentence.

You drop an anime but give a good rating, how is that any "good"? Something can't be both "good" and "you didn't like it". That sounds absurd.


Jan 5, 3:10 PM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to uyuryazar
@Desmascarado Yours are factually wrong. In fact, you prove yourself wrong in the same sentence.

You drop an anime but give a good rating, how is that any "good"? Something can't be both "good" and "you didn't like it". That sounds absurd.


@uyuryazar Yes, I tend to be contradictory, which makes your tantrum after being refuted even more embarrassing.
Jan 5, 3:39 PM

Offline
Mar 2020
134
Reply to uyuryazar
All aside, imagine watching a single episode and give it a score... I am telling you 8329 users.
@uyuryazar I'd like to mention that the episode is 3 episode long and that it will change over the release of the anime in the next 11 weeks, while I also agree that its too early to rate (I will change my rating in the future), removing ratings from people who dropped it at one episode makes no sense.
If you like doors welcome to the club Door Lovers!
Jan 5, 4:04 PM
Offline
Jul 2019
15
Reply to Desmascarado
@uyuryazar Yes, I tend to be contradictory, which makes your tantrum after being refuted even more embarrassing.
@Desmascarado You don't make sense. I need a translator for your gibberish, assuming you are actually trying to tell something.
Jan 6, 3:15 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
1071
@MemphisTango Idk it felt very force, also one of the biggest reason why I feel its gonna fell off is the side characters(those holy knights), they feel like an npc very one note and dumb. I know they have prejudice to the heroes, but not to the point they make very dumb remarks that it feels like to me a force conflict. But I’d be glad to be wrong, just setting up my expectations early on to not get disappointed.
Jan 6, 4:54 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to Angel_crush1
@MemphisTango Idk it felt very force, also one of the biggest reason why I feel its gonna fell off is the side characters(those holy knights), they feel like an npc very one note and dumb. I know they have prejudice to the heroes, but not to the point they make very dumb remarks that it feels like to me a force conflict. But I’d be glad to be wrong, just setting up my expectations early on to not get disappointed.
@Angel_crush1 The knights are tertiary, not secondary, characters.

In case you haven't noticed, they are NPCs represented by Kivia.
The only knights who gained any prominence were that group from the beginning, and even they are tertiary characters. So your complaint is something like, "Wow, these extras are treated as extras by the narrative" ...?
Jan 6, 8:32 AM
Offline
Oct 2018
823
Reply to Pablo_Neruda1
Shield Hero is literally better than this.
@Pablo_Neruda1 in your dreams.
Jan 6, 8:40 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
1116

you've only watched one episode and haven't even read the light novel dawg. sit yo ass down and quit glazing it because of the god tier animation, it's annoying.
Jan 6, 8:42 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
1116
Fayez0001 said:
Pablo_Neruda1 said:
Shield Hero is literally better than this.

Ragebait used to be believable...

you haven't read the light novel and you're glazing it from the first episode when you know nothing about it. man, people like you are the textbook definition of being oblivious. chill out, it's embarrassing.
Jan 6, 9:54 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to Pablo_Neruda1
Fayez0001 said:
Pablo_Neruda1 said:
Shield Hero is literally better than this.

Ragebait used to be believable...

you haven't read the light novel and you're glazing it from the first episode when you know nothing about it. man, people like you are the textbook definition of being oblivious. chill out, it's embarrassing.
@Pablo_Neruda1 Look, both can be good, you know?

I've read both and I like both, the same goes for your anime. Don't fall for this talk about starting fights between fandoms, that's just rage bait.
Jan 6, 10:00 AM
Offline
Dec 2022
1116
Desmascarado said:
@Pablo_Neruda1 Look, both can be good, you know?

I've read both and I like both, the same goes for your anime. Don't fall for this talk about starting fights between fandoms, that's just rage bait.

I never said it was not good, it's average at best from what I've seen so far in the light novel but overall still better than most of the recent garbage power fantasy slops that have been gushing out of Japan but yeah, you're right and I agree, no idea why niggas be jumping me.
Jan 7, 8:24 AM
Offline
May 2025
1
As a fan of the original light novels, this is easily one of the best series I’ve read in years. What really stands out is how it avoids the usual mid-series slump. It doesn’t waste time on pointless slice-of-life filler and always keeps the story moving forward.
Jan 7, 8:30 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
1071
Reply to Desmascarado
@Angel_crush1 The knights are tertiary, not secondary, characters.

In case you haven't noticed, they are NPCs represented by Kivia.
The only knights who gained any prominence were that group from the beginning, and even they are tertiary characters. So your complaint is something like, "Wow, these extras are treated as extras by the narrative" ...?
@Desmascarado well good authors I have come a crossed don’t do that, especially in a fantasy world extra characters feeling like extra(also I’m tagging along kivia the knight leader with this complain) as you call it makes the world less captivating. At best I can see this show having a 6/10 story telling which is fine cause the animation is still pretty good.
Jan 7, 8:37 AM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to Angel_crush1
@Desmascarado well good authors I have come a crossed don’t do that, especially in a fantasy world extra characters feeling like extra(also I’m tagging along kivia the knight leader with this complain) as you call it makes the world less captivating. At best I can see this show having a 6/10 story telling which is fine cause the animation is still pretty good.
@Angel_crush1 Like I said, you're complaining about extras being treated like extras, and with a "criticism" like that, I shouldn't even pay attention to you.
Jan 7, 12:24 PM
Offline
Jan 2016
126
Now that's not fair, it's not generic isekai harem. It's a harem where for some reason the author keeps making little kids flock to him.
Jan 7, 1:41 PM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to CalorieEnchilada
Now that's not fair, it's not generic isekai harem. It's a harem where for some reason the author keeps making little kids flock to him.
@CalorieEnchilada Unfortunately for you, No.
Jan 7, 3:43 PM
Offline
Dec 2022
2953
uhhh, so in your words, Shield Hero fell off after Naofumi got his revenge? y'all are so funny, lmfao. Shield Hero was never a revenge fantasy/isekai anime. Naofumi's revenge was the main focus of season 1, not the whole story. jeez.
it's fine if you say you don't like the story after S1 anymore but saying "it fell off after Naofumi got his revenge" is dumb and invalid. the story expans beyond just that after S1...idk if this is rage bait but I'm gonna stop talking.

honestly, animation aside, which this anime takes over Shield Hero (as a fan of Shield Hero, I won't deny this), Shield Hero is still better than Sentenced to be a Hero imo (yes, I've read the LN of both).
CheliosXJan 7, 3:46 PM
Jan 7, 4:53 PM
Offline
Aug 2023
944
Reply to CheliosX
uhhh, so in your words, Shield Hero fell off after Naofumi got his revenge? y'all are so funny, lmfao. Shield Hero was never a revenge fantasy/isekai anime. Naofumi's revenge was the main focus of season 1, not the whole story. jeez.
it's fine if you say you don't like the story after S1 anymore but saying "it fell off after Naofumi got his revenge" is dumb and invalid. the story expans beyond just that after S1...idk if this is rage bait but I'm gonna stop talking.

honestly, animation aside, which this anime takes over Shield Hero (as a fan of Shield Hero, I won't deny this), Shield Hero is still better than Sentenced to be a Hero imo (yes, I've read the LN of both).
@CheliosX Comparing only the light novels, Shield Hero is better, but it has some bad narrative quirks from the author, some volumes are far below average, and most fights are poorly described.

Sentenced to be a Hero, on the other hand, has excellent fight construction and execution, and its secondary characters are better. I say this appreciating both works, although I've read many more volumes of Shield Hero than of Sentenced.
Jan 7, 4:54 PM
Offline
Dec 2022
2953
yes yes, well said. all in all, Shield Hero is better even though it has its flaws.
W words.
Jan 7, 6:26 PM
Offline
Dec 2018
17
Shield Hero didnt go down hill cos of the revenge, but the pacing got messed up so much, even the last season has some bad pacing.
It is really common due to how anime is not made by the same people.
Like one punch man had an insane first season, it was alot of people at the time anime that got them into anime, season 2 happend it was bad, awful pace and animation, we got season three which was so much worse.
It is a big issue with how anime is made.
Same thing happend with Mushoku Tensei.
Jan 8, 11:16 AM
Offline
Jan 2016
126
Reply to Desmascarado
@CalorieEnchilada Unfortunately for you, No.
@Desmascarado Why unfortunately for me?
Jan 8, 2:22 PM

Offline
Sep 2018
106
Reply to cugel
Shield Hero didnt go down hill cos of the revenge, but the pacing got messed up so much, even the last season has some bad pacing.
It is really common due to how anime is not made by the same people.
Like one punch man had an insane first season, it was alot of people at the time anime that got them into anime, season 2 happend it was bad, awful pace and animation, we got season three which was so much worse.
It is a big issue with how anime is made.
Same thing happend with Mushoku Tensei.
cugel said:

Like one punch man had an insane first season, it was alot of people at the time anime that got them into anime, season 2 happend it was bad, awful pace and animation, we got season three which was so much worse.
It is a big issue with how anime is made.

Still saying opm season 2 was bad after you've seen/heard of season 3 is unbelievable. The animation of S2 was decent on average and very good when it mattered, the pace was ok. S3 was bad on average and ok-decent where it should've mattered and the pace was bad AND they didn't follow the manga.

It is really common due to how anime is not made by the same people.
Same thing happend with Mushoku Tensei.

Now, you cannot mention Mushoku in here, because it literally had an anime studio (Bind) made for it.
Jan 10, 2:45 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
1063
Lol, there's only one way to find out, keep watching it.


Shield hero was really only enjoyable the first 4-10 episodes depending on your tolerance for stuff. At the very least I think this show has a more interesting premise, but we'll see if it's to keep itself together any longer than shield hero did.

Right now whether it's good or bad is in the hands of the source materials' story. I think it's already obvious that this is a good adaption of the source material, at least aside from how accurate it is, since I haven't read the novel.
MewsicMagicJan 10, 2:50 PM
I like to watch some anime, I like to talk about some anime, I dislike wars over some anime, but more than anything I love to live my life, anime is an enjoyable and entertaining addition onto my life but it's not my whole life.
Jan 10, 2:49 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
1063
Reply to RSGX
cugel said:

Like one punch man had an insane first season, it was alot of people at the time anime that got them into anime, season 2 happend it was bad, awful pace and animation, we got season three which was so much worse.
It is a big issue with how anime is made.

Still saying opm season 2 was bad after you've seen/heard of season 3 is unbelievable. The animation of S2 was decent on average and very good when it mattered, the pace was ok. S3 was bad on average and ok-decent where it should've mattered and the pace was bad AND they didn't follow the manga.

It is really common due to how anime is not made by the same people.
Same thing happend with Mushoku Tensei.

Now, you cannot mention Mushoku in here, because it literally had an anime studio (Bind) made for it.
@RSGX OPM S3 basically proved that OPM S2's bad animation didn't ruin the series because it was still directed pretty well and had decent pacing. Unlike S3 which had some of the worst pacing, and no offense to the director, but the directing was really messy and in most cases, outright bad.
I like to watch some anime, I like to talk about some anime, I dislike wars over some anime, but more than anything I love to live my life, anime is an enjoyable and entertaining addition onto my life but it's not my whole life.
Jan 15, 3:23 AM

Offline
Apr 2023
25
Reply to uyuryazar
All aside, imagine watching a single episode and give it a score... I am telling you 8329 users.
@uyuryazar
the show is good twin, syfm 🫩

More topics from this board

Poll: » Yuusha-kei ni Shosu: Choubatsu Yuusha 9004-tai Keimu Kiroku Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Yesterday

83 by G_Spark233 »»
7 hours ago

Poll: » Opening Influences

Liental - Today

7 by legionofbees »»
7 hours ago

Poll: » Yuusha-kei ni Shosu: Choubatsu Yuusha 9004-tai Keimu Kiroku Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Feb 19

123 by Megistus_Mona »»
Today, 1:05 AM

Poll: » Yuusha-kei ni Shosu: Choubatsu Yuusha 9004-tai Keimu Kiroku Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Marinate1016 - Dec 15, 2025

615 by MothFamily »»
Yesterday, 8:22 AM

» Ep 8 preview + staff

Desmascarado - Feb 24

5 by Desmascarado »»
Yesterday, 3:36 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login