| Because it's different. And there's a surprising lack of mantits, so yeah fuck this show |
| Not enough Kyon. |
 |
| Except for Kyon looking too young (lol), I'm fine with the new designs. Anyway, I won't blame them for not admitting this is the new and only series of Haruhi they have left, but will still pity them. Keep praying for season three folks. |
| 日本人はイッちゃってるよ あいつら未来に生きてんな |
| Not a fan of the art myself but I don't think it's anywhere near as bad as people say. ZOMG IT'S NOT TEH SAME, IT'S NOT WHAT I WANT IT TO BE THEREFORE IT SUCKS. Well, it's not really meant to be. Deal with it or drop it, easy. |
Praland said: Not enough Kyon. LEL |
 |
| I think the reason why most people hate this show is because of two things: the art style and the change in character. Most of them hate the designs because Kyon looks too much like a kid and Nagato is too moe. The characters act differently as well with Nagato being the most different. People wanted a continuation of the Haruhi franchise with more Haruhi bossing people around, more Kyon and his deadpan comments, and more emotionless Nagato. |
 |
Grusomhed said: I guess that the main reason for that is the new Nagato. She has always been a dandere and seeing her as some typical moe is kinda… odd? Nagato was always typical moe, because dandre is a moe archetype. What you are probably referring to is she is now overly cutesy and not emotionless anymore, which is the whole point of this spin off. |
 |
| Because people start watching anime WITHOUT reading the fuqin synopsis...And they expect this spinoff to be the new season of Suzumiya Haruhi...And: Drizzy_Drake said: Because it's different. Drizzy_Drake said: Because it's different. |
 |
| people compare it too much to the original and cannot manage to take this as a different series |
 |
| How about they come up with an actual story that is interesting and engaging rather than showing some random "cute" things Nagato is doing to look "cute"? |
 |
Alex35012 said: ^ This. pretty much this anime revolves around the world where things are normal like shown in Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya movie, no supernatural characters like Mikuru being a time traveller, Itsuki being an esper, and Yuki being an alien created by some Thought Entity. Yuki Nagato here is what would be the Yuki from that normal world, so of course she acts differently. Though I do agree that KyoAni should've done this series to make consistency with the art style. But hopefully I can overlook that as time passes.I think the reason why most people hate this show is because of two things: the art style and the change in character. Most of them hate the designs because Kyon looks too much like a kid and Nagato is too moe. The characters act differently as well with Nagato being the most different. People wanted a continuation of the Haruhi franchise with more Haruhi bossing people around, more Kyon and his deadpan comments, and more emotionless Nagato. |
 |
chaosflame5 said: Though I do agree that KyoAni should've done this series to make consistency with the art style. But hopefully I can overlook that as time passes. People still would have complained if it had the same art style... for having the same art style. |
| 日本人はイッちゃってるよ あいつら未来に生きてんな |
DawnJ said: chaosflame5 said: Though I do agree that KyoAni should've done this series to make consistency with the art style. But hopefully I can overlook that as time passes. People still would have complained if it had the same art style... for having the same art style. The score would have been 8+ (as long as Nagato was closer to her movie shy self) but yeah they would have complained. |
 |
| Because people have high expectations without knowing anything about the manga it was adapted from. More over, they are not Haruhi fans and just want to voice their hate, considering this is much easier to attack than the original franchise. A true Haruhi fan would have jumped out of the chair the moment Haruhi appeared on screen (I did, symbolically) |
Haruhi ism  It's fun, isn't it? |
konatachan80 said: yaiba064 said: Because people have high expectations without knowing anything about the manga it was adapted from. More over, they are not Haruhi fans and just want to voice their hate, considering this is much easier to attack than the original franchise. A true Haruhi fan would have jumped out of the chair the moment Haruhi appeared on screen (I did, symbolically) I didn't, but I do appreciate her antics. High expectations is a given for a Haruhi-based series, which is even more reason for keeping or even improving the art and so on. This seems to do the opposite. Again, you haven't seen the manga. The art of this show is lifted directly from there.. |
Haruhi ism It's fun, isn't it? |
konatachan80 said: Seriously,Having the same artstyle?After 5 whole years?Sounds legit...EVEN IF,by a %0.01 chance they decide to do a new season for actual Suzumiya Haruhi AND KyoAni makes it...EVEN IF that was the case artstyle would still be different...DawnJ said: People still would have complained if it had the same art style... for having the same art style. It probably would've been less complaints. It doesn't make sense when the art and so on changes alot (for the worse) just because its a different timeline. |
| |
| Someone in an earlier thread said this was pretty much a fan-fiction made into an anime and that was all I needed to hear. So not comparing it to the original series made me enjoy it so far. |
| I think it's ok, Not good and not bad... only thing i don't like it is the Kyon face... The other characteris is ok.. but kyon is ugly... |
| People don't "hate it", they're just dissapointed... and I can understand. The art is questionnable (for example Kyon's younger head doesn't really fit his voice now), Haruhi animation/art was something impressive back when it aired, this shows now is just in the average 2015 animation (even the OP, so many static shots not fitting the catchy song). The characters are not all lost, and one could say that the plotline is different and so Yuki is, but it's only for the worst : ultra-cliché shy girl blushing everytime, acting like a child, they could gave her that "new personnality with feels" without making that. Please, Haruhi story was actually good with girl characters being quite original... not like this new Nagato. Characters like Tsuruya are still as good, but the sarcastic comments which made Kyon so good to hear are nearly nowhere to be seen in ep2 actually. The overall story is actually.. well is there even a story ? Since it's only ep2 I'm still hoping for something big to land into the show, but actually... I mean look at that romance, one could say it's "cute" but it's just déjà-vu and childish.. I guess some people like this like that but why putting that in Haruhi, any other world and characters could have exactly that kind of thing, using this serie's characters and world is a waste. So no hate, but a lot of people started animes with Haruhi or at least have some great memories of it, please understand it can be painful to watch this half-baked cliché romance using Haruhi's world. |
ZiassanApr 13, 2015 5:48 PM
| I'm ok with everything even the fact that this is an alternate universe meaning there SHOULD be no relation/connection/relevance to the Haruhi plot/story line whatsoever but... KYON's FACE is something I CANNOT GET USED TO... Every time that tiny round shaped head smiles, I laugh bacause it is just too funny ahahahahaha. But overall, I'm excited for this anime. Since I like slice-of-life anime/school animes |
| I just added this anime to my ignore list. They should have leave this in mangaland for eternity. |
| internet is a cruel mistress |
booyah10 said: This isnt "alternate universe",this is just an "alternate setting with same characters",made for the fans who enjoyed alternate NagatoI'm ok with everything even the fact that this is an alternate universe meaning there SHOULD be no relation/connection/relevance to the Haruhi plot/story line whatsoever but... This: hulksWAGON said: Someone in an earlier thread said this was pretty much a fan-fiction made into an anime and that was all I needed to hear. |
| |
| I sorta went into to this with a fresh mindset. The fact I watched Haruhi once over a year ago is kinda helping. Not gonna lie I'm enjoying this more than I thought. loneywizard said: u srs?This: hulksWAGON said: Someone in an earlier thread said this was pretty much a fan-fiction made into an anime and that was all I needed to hear. |
Fo-Fai said: about what may i ask?loneywizard said: u srs?This: This was never a serious manga,you can understand it by even reading 1 chapter...It was something like a doujin for fans by fans...I dont know if it actually get published in a magazine(apparently it got published in Young Ace) or not but i know that Mangaka of this series doesnt even have any other manga... |
| |
loneywizard said: Because people start watching anime WITHOUT reading the fuqin synopsis...And they expect this spinoff to be the new season of Suzumiya Haruhi...And: Drizzy_Drake said: Because it's different. yaiba064 said: Because people have high expectations without knowing anything about the manga it was adapted from. I already said this before. Most people came watching the series without having no idea what it is about and from where it was adapted from. The manga is a slice-of-life romance comedy with the same characters from Haruhi |
-miraiiApr 14, 2015 2:29 AM
 "In the past few months since we met, I've shared many memories with Nagato. Though I've also shared memories with Haruhi, Asahina-san and Koizumi, I found that I've experienced more events with Nagato in particular. In fact, every situation seems to involve her. I might as well mention this, she's probably the only person to cause the bell within me to shake the most vigorously..." ~ Kyon, TMOSH |
| Because people thought this was the third season. (because autism) Because people think that this ruined the chance of KyoAni ever making a third season. (KyoAni doesn't care about Haruhi, Free is more likely of getting a third season than Haruhi) Because people think it's taking place in the main Haruhi universe. (despite the title, synopsis and the first episode saying otherwise) Because people prefer anime girls without any character over moeblobs obsessed with turkey. (sounds like a penis metaphor) Because people think that KyoAni's Haruhi had actual plot. (top kek) Because somehow a different design makes the whole show bad. (Oh boy, Kyon doesnt look like that bland guy with a long face anymore, he's now a bland guy with a round face, gasp, the horror) Because it lacks Haruhi. (which is somehow a bad thing, apparently) Bottom line is: Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S1 is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S2 is garbage. Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is already an improvement over Season 2. |
 "Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
ZetaZaku said: The only good thing about that series was the movie which they proved by making endless eight just for the sake of movie...So that doesnt mean much honestly...Bottom line is: Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S1 is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S2 is garbage. Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is already an improvement over Season 2. |
| |
ZetaZaku said: Because people thought this was the third season. (because autism) Because people think that this ruined the chance of KyoAni ever making a third season. (KyoAni doesn't care about Haruhi, Free is more likely of getting a third season than Haruhi) Because people think it's taking place in the main Haruhi universe. (despite the title, synopsis and the first episode saying otherwise) Because people prefer anime girls without any character over moeblobs obsessed with turkey. (sounds like a penis metaphor) Because people think that KyoAni's Haruhi had actual plot. (top kek) Because somehow a different design makes the whole show bad. (Oh boy, Kyon doesnt look like that bland guy with a long face anymore, he's now a bland guy with a round face, gasp, the horror) Because it lacks Haruhi. (which is somehow a bad thing, apparently) Bottom line is: Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S1 is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S2 is garbage. Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is already an improvement over Season 2. ^THIS! But also I must say that this series heart was and will always be the bitter Kyon. And because he isn't here, obviously the Internet is gonna complain about it. |
 |
| I don't hate it and I'm all for a different take on a series with a change in characters plot etc (otherwise why else make a spin off?), I started this knowing it'd be different/unrelated and that it's a slice-of-life (which I'm usually fond of). I think the issue is that the overall result is... boring and cliched in not a good way? My main problem is with the characters - they could had be tweaked to be different but still interesting/intriguing in a new way, but instead they're just reduced to very bland characters - still likeable, but bland. I wouldn't have found this interesting even if it wasn't a Haruhi spin-off. But I'm willing to stick by for a few more episodes to see if it grows on me. |
 |
| People just can't accept a change to their favorite serie, I don't think you really need to ask this question since it's as clear as the day. |
Rapidfir3Pho3nix said: People are stupid and can't grasp that this is the alternate timeline that was shown in the movie. Also, no the drawings are not worse, they're drawn differently to highlight the fact that this is a different timeline; it's an artistic choice. Also, I was told these drawings are closer to the manga so there's that as well. +1 Also people want a reason to hate the series since it's not canon. |
| What if the Hokey Pokey is what it is all about? |
Thai777 said: People just can't accept a change to their favorite serie, I don't think you really need to ask this question since it's as clear as the day. It's an unfair way to look down on people thinking this anime is bad. It's not that much about being different from the original, it's about everything that makes a show : characters feel flat (like Kyon bitter comments are watered to the usual normal guy, Yuki became the super cliché already seen 1000 times shy girl, and so on), the art is just ok (while the original serie was on-top back when it aired), and the story/interactions are boring. I mean just look at those "romance" scenes in ep1/2, even in the restaurant in the ep3, it's so archetype and sound like a fanfic wrote by a high school student. It's not about hating, but about being disappointed by such a waste, the canon universe & story was original and interesting, no problem with a "fan" story if it's good too, but here it's just flat and cliché. |
Ziassan said: Thai777 said: People just can't accept a change to their favorite serie, I don't think you really need to ask this question since it's as clear as the day. It's an unfair way to look down on people thinking this anime is bad. It's not that much about being different from the original, it's about everything that makes a show : characters feel flat (like Kyon bitter comments are watered to the usual normal guy, Yuki became the super cliché already seen 1000 times shy girl, and so on), the art is just ok (while the original serie was on-top back when it aired), and the story/interactions are boring. I mean just look at those "romance" scenes in ep1/2, even in the restaurant in the ep3, it's so archetype and sound like a fanfic wrote by a high school student. It's not about hating, but about being disappointed by such a waste, the canon universe & story was original and interesting, no problem with a "fan" story if it's good too, but here it's just flat and cliché. Yes Kyon is different and nagato is boring. Doesn't change the other character which in my opinion have the time to shine like asakura or tsuruya. Either way I never liked Kyon that much but it does hurt to see Nagato so cliché, but still it's not that bad for some people like me. The art isn't that bad but it's typical for anime and animation is average so there is no complaint. And it's different studio, I don't know why the art would bother you that much, so much anime has different studio for different season, this is just a spin-off calm down. Interaction is subjective, I like some character interaction so it doesn't make it bad. Well if you are disappointed it's because you went withsome expectation. I just thought of it as something else than haruhi and I was fine. In conclusion that type of story just don't fit you and the fact that it's a spin-off of your favorite serie make it even worse for you. This serie isn't bad, but it's nothing to show off either. |
| Quiet Yuki > Moe Yuki Loud Haruhi >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Moe Yuki |
#CHEXIT |
ares5566 said: Thai777 said: Well if you are disappointed it's because you went withsome expectation. I just thought of it as something else than haruhi and I was fine. In conclusion that type of story just don't fit you and the fact that it's a spin-off of your favorite serie make it even worse for you. This serie isn't bad, but it's nothing to show off either. It's a haruhi spin-off. If they wanted to make a story that they though could stand on it's own it would do just that. Not comparing it to the source material would be idiotic. While a spin-off can be tonally or thematically different the standard I'm comparing it to is the QUALITY of the original. This is bad as a romcom. It's boring and bland and the characters aren't interesting in the slightest. Their personality is so mute that you don't feel anything for them unless you compare them to the original. First the author of both aren't the same so of course their quality and content would differ. If there is different author I don't think you need to compare both serie. And seriously comparing anime quality while they have different studio is stupid, all studio has different art and animation. That's your subjective opinion of it being bland and that the character's personality are blank. |
| The art style isn't as bad as I thought. I like how Kyon is animated. They could've did a better job on Yuki but she is still cute. I've always been a Yuki fan so my opinion is a bit biased but who cares. I can't wait to see how this storyline goes. |
 |
| Not moe enough |
  |
 I can only imagine the meeting went something like this |
The best anime is the Road to El Dorado |
| >Using an overdriven storyline; nobody bats an eye >Changes the artstyle; everyone goes batshit insane Satelight's artstyle is faithful to the manga, and I wouldn't have it any other way. I can't believe people actually dislike this show due to their own misconceived expectations. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 26, 2015 |
88 |
by _MushiRock11_
»»
9 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 22, 2015 |
84 |
by Seashantyenjoyer
»»
Feb 21, 2025 12:04 PM |
|
Poll: » Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jun 5, 2015 |
145 |
by Sam_Vector
»»
Dec 14, 2024 10:44 PM |
|
Poll: » Nagato Yuki-chan no Shoushitsu Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 29, 2015 |
89 |
by Sam_Vector
»»
Dec 14, 2024 10:20 PM |
|
» Is there anything to this show other than generic high school romcom hijinks?tehnik - Nov 4, 2024 |
2 |
by RudeRedis
»»
Nov 4, 2024 7:28 AM |