We all know that:
Okay I get the rules of the voting thing but I don't understand why does participants being in odd number matters for a final voting. I'm asking this because what I really want to ask is that what if every player voted to exactly one different person and all/none of them lost their paper? i.e. what if everyone votes:
If this happens then what? A final round will happen and solve it? |
| that's a tie, so the vote will continue until the tie breaks. isn't it obvious? the odd number is relevant in that the tie breaker could only last one round if it were the case that 2 people tied. They probably didn't consider the possibility of a 5 way tie happening, which would've required the girls to find out about the game, discuss it, and cooperate, risking betrayal. I'm sure that a 5 way tie would've carried on for a couple of rounds until the gms would arbitrarily pick one of them, probably based on the first paper to be deposited. |
Reply to HOnline23
5 participants voting for 2 people can only be
5-0
4-1
or 3-2.
and you are really thinking WAAAAAY to hard bro
5-0
4-1
or 3-2.
and you are really thinking WAAAAAY to hard bro
| @HOnline23 I'm talking about a result of 1-1-1-1-1, whether by cooperation or by chance. |
| I would like to think it is some kind of secret ending where everyone is saved. |
Reply to IhnalakoKaina
that's a tie, so the vote will continue until the tie breaks. isn't it obvious?
the odd number is relevant in that the tie breaker could only last one round if it were the case that 2 people tied. They probably didn't consider the possibility of a 5 way tie happening, which would've required the girls to find out about the game, discuss it, and cooperate, risking betrayal.
I'm sure that a 5 way tie would've carried on for a couple of rounds until the gms would arbitrarily pick one of them, probably based on the first paper to be deposited.
the odd number is relevant in that the tie breaker could only last one round if it were the case that 2 people tied. They probably didn't consider the possibility of a 5 way tie happening, which would've required the girls to find out about the game, discuss it, and cooperate, risking betrayal.
I'm sure that a 5 way tie would've carried on for a couple of rounds until the gms would arbitrarily pick one of them, probably based on the first paper to be deposited.
| @IhnalakoKaina Rather than the gm picking one, my guess will be the "audiences" will do an additional round. BTW 2 out of 5 players had already known from the start in this game. If all 5 players in the group know each other like the 4 in the actual show, and their lead is one of those who figured it out fast, the tie could actually happen. The leader could tell the whole group about the voting game, how to vote a 5 way tie, and time to brace themselves way before doing the walk. But of course avoiding serious mistakes caused by emotion and pride, and refusing abandoning teammates like what mishiro did would be necessary to make the others to trust your plan and not betray out of fear out of being betrayed. |
Reply to HaruyukiIsCute
@HOnline23 I'm talking about a result of 1-1-1-1-1, whether by cooperation or by chance.
| @HaruyukiIsCute In such a case tie breaker is only between those that got voted using the "strong" votes. The ones that got voted with drawer paper become safe, which reduces the number of participants for the tie breaker. At this point there is either 2 or 3 left, 2 ends at next tie break and 3 could need 1 more tie break in the 2-2-1 case. Only loophole I see, is what happens if a person that is now safe refuses the vote. That makes it less than 5 votes and breaks the game, unless there is another rule for that. |
watsymJan 29, 6:36 AM
| if they knew the 6th girls name they could have voted her, that's the loophole but they didn't because she pre died ... |
     |
| If there's a tie then they'll keep going until there's a loser, this rule you yourself mentioned [there could be a final voting if thing still can't be settled] is practically that. People saying you're thinking too hard are wrong, it's fine to talk about hypotheticals even if they wouldn't happen given the voting's circumstances in the anime. |
Reply to Ionliosite2
If there's a tie then they'll keep going until there's a loser, this rule you yourself mentioned [there could be a final voting if thing still can't be settled] is practically that. People saying you're thinking too hard are wrong, it's fine to talk about hypotheticals even if they wouldn't happen given the voting's circumstances in the anime.
| @Ionliosite2 The key to this game's logic is that this arc is meant to show that Yuki isn't actually a cold, cynical player, but a person capable of empathy and a desire to help others escape. And how this clashes with reality. So we got something that Yuki wanted to save and even felt sympathy for Mishiro, although one still had to become the scapegoat. |
 |
Reply to NotBony
DeityNyxCiara-_- said:
if they knew the 6th girls name they could have voted her, that's the loophole but they didn't because she pre died ...
if they knew the 6th girls name they could have voted her, that's the loophole but they didn't because she pre died ...
they couldn’t vote for her, the rules said voting for someone who’s not in the room isn’t allowed
| @NotBony I meant could have dragged her body in... |
|
I think If Someone thought that well to drag the body from the starting floor by Either Knowing what would happen through the hints Or Simply being cautious to prepare for any possibilities Then Whether the game master allow it or not while stating the rules could be affected by how the audience reacted. The audience could go either way. They might think this loophole is ridiculous and anti-dramatic, or find it interesting to see a clever attempt. |
Reply to HaruyukiIsCute
I think
If
Someone thought that well to drag the body from the starting floor by
Either
Knowing what would happen through the hints
Or
Simply being cautious to prepare for any possibilities
Then
Whether the game master allow it or not while stating the rules could be affected by how the audience reacted.
The audience could go either way. They might think this loophole is ridiculous and anti-dramatic, or find it interesting to see a clever attempt.
| @HaruyukiIsCute It wouldn't take too long, because over one hour remains so they could go back, someone can climb someone else's soldiers to get to floor three because stairs were broken... Than Yukki might've so op that she learned the place of every trap... So I think it would be reasonable... 70 percent death rrate means one gotta die and a second maybe at the least... And why would there be 6 pods in the end unless to hint that, I think every game has a loophole but we gotta find it ourselves... In the 2nd game of Ep 1 I think that passing the key to person on the ryt and repaying would have saved everyone... But alas the survival rate was always meant to be 50 % I'm legit waiting for Vol 5 to be translated to see Yukki in game 60 and sh!t... |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shibou Yuugi de Meshi wo Kuu. Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Feb 25 |
63 |
by Neneaux
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» [Spoilers] Shibou Yuugi de Meshi wo Kuu is an allusion to the prostitution of young girlsWillKamio - 11 hours ago |
8 |
by iirayuki
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shibou Yuugi de Meshi wo Kuu. Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Feb 18 |
208 |
by stevejawbs
»»
11 hours ago |
|
» Best high stakes game you’ve seen ?silversurfeer - Feb 25 |
12 |
by CorLeonis-_-
»»
Today, 9:28 AM |
|
Poll: » Shibou Yuugi de Meshi wo Kuu. Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Feb 11 |
92 |
by zydraholic
»»
Yesterday, 4:24 PM |