Who is the strongest Key heroine? (in combat)
Kawasumi Mai (Kanon)
3.3%
6
Minase Nayuki (Kanon)
0.0%
0
Misaka Shiori (Kanon)
1.1%
2
Sawatari Makoto (Kanon)
0.5%
1
Tsukimiya Ayu (Kanon)
2.7%
5
Kamio Misuzu (Air)
1.6%
3
Kirishima Kano (Air)
0.0%
0
Toono Minagi (Air)
0.0%
0
Furukawa Nagisa (Clannad)
8.7%
16
Fujibayashi Kyou (Clannad)
4.9%
9
Sakagami Tomoyo (Clannad)
16.9%
31
Ichinose Kotomi (Clannad)
2.2%
4
Ibuki Fuuko (Clannad)
0.5%
1
Hoshino Yumemi (Planetarian)
1.6%
3
Natsume Rin (Little Busters!)
6.6%
12
Kamikita Komari (Little Busters!)
0.0%
0
Noumi Kudryavka (Little Busters!)
2.2%
4
Kurugaya Yuiko (Little Busters!)
9.8%
18
Saigusa Haruka (Little Busters!)
1.1%
2
Nishizono Mio (Little Busters!)
0.0%
0
Futaki Kanata (Little Busters!)
1.1%
2
Sasasegawa Sasami (Little Busters!)
1.1%
2
Tokido Saya (Little Busters!)
1.6%
3
Kanbe Kotori (Rewrite)
1.1%
2
Senri Akane (Rewrite)
0.5%
1
Ootori Chihaya (Rewrite)
3.8%
7
Nakatsu Shizuru (Rewrite)
7.1%
13
Konohana Lucia (Rewrite)
8.2%
15
Kagari (Rewrite)
11.5%
21
183 votes
| Because I enjoy causing trouble. But yes since I made a poll for the male protagonist I think Heroines deserve one too, even thought there is a ton of them, I didn't bother including One because even though Tactics is kinda Key they weren't Key yet. Here are some result speculations Tomoyo and Kyou are both pretty strong and have a huge fanbase (because Clannad is the only anime people watch and is like the best anime ever, or so they say.) and Tomoyo had a popular route. (I didn't like it that much btw, Besides her popularity clashes with my Kyou favoritism.) Mai will get some votes. People who read Rewrite will vote for Rewrite characters. Kagari is no doubt the strongest but since next to no one actually read Rewrite she will actually lose in the polls Those who have read Little Busters will either vote for Yuiko or Saya. Depends on if you like guns or not. Sa-chan will vote for Sasami. Or maybe Kyou, my money is on Sasami. Lucia and Shizuru are good candidates but so is Akane, Zombie lovers will vote for Kotori. Hoshino Yumemi really don't belong on this poll A-Total-Apple said: Hmmm do the characters get Weapons of choice (Signature Weapons) Mai gets her Katana, Kyou gets her Dictionary Kotomi gets her violin Rin gets Aristotle, Yuusaku, Cobain, Fyodor, Hokusai, Jackie, Tezuka, Gates, Einstein, Fabre, Audrey, and Hitler(12 Cats) Noumi get Strelka and Belka Mio gets a random Science Club weapon Yuiko gets replica of murasame. Saya gets her Pistol and her Sniper rifle Kotori gets Chibimoth, Zombie Rikako with Chainsaw, Zombie Keisuke with 12G Shotgun Chihaya gets her choice of telephone poles Shizuru gets her knives and dual wield UMPs Lucia has her trademark kantana Kagari has ribbons and her song obviously |
blasterionFeb 4, 2013 6:46 PM
 |
| Not again... |
 |
| Combat-wise? How is that even a fair comparison between series? I vote Nagisa, for trollz. |
| Kyou. KYAHHHHH |
 |
| tomoyo definitely the strongest.... yeah true i haven't played rewrite yet. so i don't know about that. XD |
     |
| Mai seems like a pretty good contender. |
SleepingEntity said: Combat-wise? How is that even a fair comparison between series? I vote Nagisa, for trollz. If you really want to troll you could have voted for the robot that got blown apart. |
blasterionJan 26, 2013 3:16 AM
|
blasterion said: SleepingEntity said: Combat-wise? How is that even a fair comparison between series? I vote Nagisa, for trollz. If you really want to troll you could have voted for the robot that got blown apart. Even the Planetarian has more combat potential than Nagisa. I mean, who knows what you can outfit her arms with. A little tinkering in a post-apocalyptic junkyard, some (a lot of) reprogramming and voila! Your very own robotic killer soldier! |
SleepingEntity said: blasterion said: SleepingEntity said: Combat-wise? How is that even a fair comparison between series? I vote Nagisa, for trollz. If you really want to troll you could have voted for the robot that got blown apart. Even the Planetarian has more combat potential than Nagisa. I mean, who knows what you can outfit her arms with. A little tinkering in a post-apocalyptic junkyard, some (a lot of) reprogramming and voila! Your very own robotic killer soldier! From Planetarian to Aigis (Persona 3) That would be quite a sight! first we need wrist guns, and missile racks in her legs, Expandable wings on her back too! |
blasterionJan 26, 2013 4:27 AM
|
| I vote for Lucia.... I don't think Akane is really strong at all. Lucia spoiler Akane spoiler Kotori spoiler Shizuru spoiler Chihaya spoiler ---edit, shoot~ I missed the Key in the vote lol! |
kuroikishi said: I vote for Lucia.... I don't think Akane is really strong at all. Lucia spoiler Akane spoiler Kotori spoiler Shizuru spoiler Chihaya spoiler I am a Lucia fan, but I think Shizuru is stronger, mainly because Kuroishiki, measuring power levels in Shimakos xD |
|
| My bet is on Shizuru. Yeah, Kagari is super strong |
 |
helski666 said: My bet is on Shizuru. Yeah, Kagari is super strong Well Kotori route Shizuru did shoot Key with a high caliber rifle. Which obvious Key didn't take very well. |
|
| Seeing that this is a contest of strength, I'll probably vote for Tomoyo, although I don't really know how to compare everyone's force, I'll just go with my favourite to avoid confusion and meaningless rationalization. |
| Don't think too deeply about it. You'll get a headache. |
kuroikishi said: I vote for Lucia.... I don't think Akane is really strong at all. Lucia spoiler Akane spoiler Kotori spoiler Shizuru spoiler Chihaya spoiler ---edit, shoot~ I missed the Key in the vote lol! This is my opinion and my opinion only. I also based them on not only power level but combat experience. this is pure speculation but estimated power levels are Kawasumi Mai (Kanon) 5 Shimakos Minase Nayuki (Kanon) 0.04 Shimakos Misaka Shiori (Kanon) 0 Shimakos Sawatari Makoto (Kanon) 0.08 Shimakos Tsukimiya Ayu (Kanon) 0.002 Shimakos Kamio Misuzu (Air) 0.06 Shimakos Kirishima Kano (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Toono Minagi (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Furukawa Nagisa (Clannad) 0 Shimakos Fujibayashi Kyou (Clannad) 0.8 Shimakos Sakagami Tomoyo (Clannad) 3.7 Shimakos Ichinose Kotomi (Clannad) 7.5 Shimakos Ibuki Fuuko (Clannad) 0.002 Shimakos Hoshino Yumemi (Planetarian) 0 Shimakos Natsume Rin (Little Busters!) 1.2 Shimakos Kamikita Komari (Little Busters!) 0.08 Shimakos Noumi Kudryavka (Little Busters!) 0.8 Shimakos Kurugaya Yuiko (Little Busters!) 9.5 Shimakos Saigusa Haruka (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Nishizono Mio (Little Busters!) 0.3 Shimakos Futaki Kanata (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Sasasegawa Sasami (Little Busters!) 1.3 Shimakos Tokido Saya (Little Busters!) 9.0 Shimakos Kanbe Kotori (Rewrite) 5.6 Shimakos Senri Akane (Rewrite) 6.0 Shimakos Ootori Chihaya (Rewrite) 30.5 Shimakos Nakatsu Shizuru (Rewrite) 56 Shimakos Konohana Lucia (Rewrite) 68 Shimakos Kagari (Rewrite) (your vote) 75 Shimakos Guardian Heroines are just that much stronger |
blasterionJan 26, 2013 1:19 PM
|
| Obviously yumemi... |
blasterion said: Tomoyo and Kyou are both pretty strong and have a huge fanbase (because Clannad is the only anime people watch and is like the best anime ever, or so they say.) and Tomoyo had a popular route. (I didn't like it that much btw, Besides her popularity clashes with my Kyou favoritism.) Kagari is no doubt the strongest but since next to no one actually read Rewrite she will actually lose in the polls This |
 |
 Gao Gao Stegosaurus =D |
|
A-Total-Apple said: Hmmm do the characters get Weapons of choice (Signature Weapons) Magi gets her Katana, Kyou gets he Dictionary Kotomi gets her violin Rin gets Aristotle, Yuusaku, Cobain, Fyodor, Hokusai, Jackie, Tezuka, Gates, Einstein, Fabre, Audrey, and Hitler(12 Cats) Noumi get Strelka and Belka Mio gets a random Science Club weapon Yuiko gets replica of murasame. Saya gets her Pistol and her Sniper rifle Kotori gets Chibimoth, Zombie Rikako with Chainsaw, Zombie Keisuke with 12G Shotgun Chihaya gets her choice of telephone poles Shizuru gets her knives and dual wield UMPs Lucia has her trademark kantana Kagari has ribbons obviously. |
blasterionJan 27, 2013 5:11 PM
|
| For now, I'll vote for Kurugaya. Still need to play Rewrite, Planetarian and watch Kanon though, so maybe I'll change the vote in the future. |
 "Like this too we met in a dirty and ugly world; Thank you for this miracle." |
| This poll sucks. Kagari needs more votes. =/ |
| I think Kotori should get zombie Rikako with Chainsaw and zombie Keisuke with 12G Pump Action Shotgun. Or else she'll have trouble competing with Chihaya Shizuru and Lucia. |
|
| This poll needs more Kanako |
Aexis0Jan 28, 2013 3:16 PM
| By strongest you mean mentally ("i can overcome anything, gambadimasu watashi! type?)" , physically (Thats a joke) or the character with biggest impact on viewer ? My choice is Nagisa (character with biggest impact on viewer) |
( Currently interested in OP MC genre. Recommendations are welcomed, preferable those yet not on my list ) |
| This is honestly a really hard poll as: non-Rewrite heroines will be easily killed by the Rewrite characters (Rewrite spoilers) I can't decide between Kagari, Shizuru, and Lucia but I'll go with Kagari D: |
|
| Actually I shouldn't have even put Nagisa or Shiori in the polls seeing how if they gotten even with in several hundred meters of Lucia, it would spell instant death for them. |
|
| Tomoyo for sure! Who else could keep kicking an airborne Sunohara? However, i haven't played rewrite yet so i dont know what to expect from them. All i know is that they are all strong. |
Javera said: Tomoyo for sure! Who else could keep kicking an airborne Sunohara? However, i haven't played rewrite yet so i dont know what to expect from them. All i know is that they are all strong. All of the Rewrite characters have massive amounts of blood stains on their hands. Except Chihaya, because she only kills familiars. |
|
xHikaru13x said: Javera said: Tomoyo for sure! Who else could keep kicking an airborne Sunohara? However, i haven't played rewrite yet so i dont know what to expect from them. All i know is that they are all strong. Try Rewrite and you WILL change your mind about the strongest in fighting after finish it I don't think Tomoyo can even go 1 on 1 against YOSHINO, Pretty sure he took down a couple of raptors himself before going down in the most glorious manner a wingman can go. |
|
GentlemanG said: Anyone voting for Kagari is really simplifying things too much, she doesn't have nearly the amount of power seem to think, she can only really defend herself, if she was so powerful she wouldn't have needed help from the occult club. That being said, I'm more concerned about the votes that Akane and Nagisa got, two people both proven to have below average strength. At least Akane can summon. Nagisa can't even do that, besides Nagisa and Shiori are both sickly they'll drop dead instant if they come in range of Lucia's poison. |
|
| Only thing I've seen is Clannad and Little Busters so Kyou and Tomoyo are my choices. |
| still don't see how Clannad Characters can defeat Little Busters in combat, And cannot see how Little Busters can defeat Rewrite girls in combat. Strongest Clannad are probably Sakagami and Fujibayashi not the type to beat Kurugaya, who is skilled with the sword and can "teleport" and Saya who is an agent and fights with a bolt gun and a Pistol. That said, Even those two wouldn't fare well in a fight against Rewrite Girls, mainly the 2 hunters, Chihaya is a bit troublesome too since she's got Sakuya's carry over skills. Kagari is more of a wild card, she could potentially be very strong or can be easily taken out by a hunter. However I don't think anyone other than Rewrite heroines has the means to take down Key. Except maybe Saya, because she can snipe key without being cut to ribbons by..... ribbons. |
blasterionFeb 10, 2013 2:49 AM
|
| 1) Tomoyo and her combo kicks. 2) Mai the 'shadow slayer'. 3) Rin feat. Dorj. 4) Kurogaya had amazing stats in my game. 5) Kotomi with her psychic violin. |
 |
| I never understood why people keep saying Tomoyo is the strongest, I mean she is, but she in no means can match, Kurugaya's speed and agility, Saya's guns, Lucia's poison, Shizuru's hunting skills, Key's defense, Chihaya's strength. I mean Tomoyo is competing against at least 5 people who has experience killing at least a small army of professionals if not dinosaurs |
|
| Not trying to be rude, but the question of who is stronger in combat is not a matter of opinion, which is why I find it somewhat pointless to make a poll about it. The decisioins made by the voters here mostly don't rely on facts but rather on 'Which ones they know and which ones they don't ' or 'which one is their favorite' For instance, someone like me who played Kanon, Clannad and LB but did not play Rewrite yet is in a bind. Looking at the openings, it's clear that the Rewrite heroines are much more powerfull in battle. But not really knowing them, which one am I supposed to vote for? Just pick a random one? Go ask someone who is more familiar with them? Most would be inclined to vote for Tomoyo/Kurugaya and be done with it, cause they are at least familiar with her. Or just not vote at all. It might have made sense to discuss the matter if the outcome wasn't certain, like Tomoyo VS Kurugaya. |
 |
| No Angel Beats characters? no Kanade? :( |
| How to Watch Naruto Without Filler (Complete): http://bit.ly/LncQif How to Watch Bleach Without Filler (Complete): http://bit.ly/y0UQTO |
blasterion said: kuroikishi said: I vote for Lucia.... I don't think Akane is really strong at all. Lucia spoiler Akane spoiler Kotori spoiler Shizuru spoiler Chihaya spoiler ---edit, shoot~ I missed the Key in the vote lol! This is my opinion and my opinion only. I also based them on not only power level but combat experience. this is pure speculation but estimated power levels are Kawasumi Mai (Kanon) 5 Shimakos Minase Nayuki (Kanon) 0.04 Shimakos Misaka Shiori (Kanon) 0 Shimakos Sawatari Makoto (Kanon) 0.08 Shimakos Tsukimiya Ayu (Kanon) 0.002 Shimakos Kamio Misuzu (Air) 0.06 Shimakos Kirishima Kano (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Toono Minagi (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Furukawa Nagisa (Clannad) 0 Shimakos Fujibayashi Kyou (Clannad) 0.8 Shimakos Sakagami Tomoyo (Clannad) 3.7 Shimakos Ichinose Kotomi (Clannad) 7.5 Shimakos Ibuki Fuuko (Clannad) 0.002 Shimakos Hoshino Yumemi (Planetarian) 0 Shimakos Natsume Rin (Little Busters!) 1.2 Shimakos Kamikita Komari (Little Busters!) 0.08 Shimakos Noumi Kudryavka (Little Busters!) 0.8 Shimakos Kurugaya Yuiko (Little Busters!) 9.5 Shimakos Saigusa Haruka (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Nishizono Mio (Little Busters!) 0.3 Shimakos Futaki Kanata (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Sasasegawa Sasami (Little Busters!) 1.3 Shimakos Tokido Saya (Little Busters!) 9.0 Shimakos Kanbe Kotori (Rewrite) 5.6 Shimakos Senri Akane (Rewrite) 6.0 Shimakos Ootori Chihaya (Rewrite) 30.5 Shimakos Nakatsu Shizuru (Rewrite) 56 Shimakos Konohana Lucia (Rewrite) 68 Shimakos Kagari (Rewrite) (your vote) 75 Shimakos Guardian Heroines are just that much stronger C'mon. Power levels are based on Yoshinos, not Shimakos. Though I wonder what the conversion rate between Yoshinos and Shimakos are. On a second note, that list is pretty accurate. Rewrite heroines should win by a landslide because of, well, superpowers and stuff. |
Saernist said: blasterion said: kuroikishi said: I vote for Lucia.... I don't think Akane is really strong at all. Lucia spoiler Akane spoiler Kotori spoiler Shizuru spoiler Chihaya spoiler ---edit, shoot~ I missed the Key in the vote lol! This is my opinion and my opinion only. I also based them on not only power level but combat experience. this is pure speculation but estimated power levels are Kawasumi Mai (Kanon) 5 Shimakos Minase Nayuki (Kanon) 0.04 Shimakos Misaka Shiori (Kanon) 0 Shimakos Sawatari Makoto (Kanon) 0.08 Shimakos Tsukimiya Ayu (Kanon) 0.002 Shimakos Kamio Misuzu (Air) 0.06 Shimakos Kirishima Kano (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Toono Minagi (Air) 0.05 Shimakos Furukawa Nagisa (Clannad) 0 Shimakos Fujibayashi Kyou (Clannad) 0.8 Shimakos Sakagami Tomoyo (Clannad) 3.7 Shimakos Ichinose Kotomi (Clannad) 7.5 Shimakos Ibuki Fuuko (Clannad) 0.002 Shimakos Hoshino Yumemi (Planetarian) 0 Shimakos Natsume Rin (Little Busters!) 1.2 Shimakos Kamikita Komari (Little Busters!) 0.08 Shimakos Noumi Kudryavka (Little Busters!) 0.8 Shimakos Kurugaya Yuiko (Little Busters!) 9.5 Shimakos Saigusa Haruka (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Nishizono Mio (Little Busters!) 0.3 Shimakos Futaki Kanata (Little Busters!) 0.5 Shimakos Sasasegawa Sasami (Little Busters!) 1.3 Shimakos Tokido Saya (Little Busters!) 9.0 Shimakos Kanbe Kotori (Rewrite) 5.6 Shimakos Senri Akane (Rewrite) 6.0 Shimakos Ootori Chihaya (Rewrite) 30.5 Shimakos Nakatsu Shizuru (Rewrite) 56 Shimakos Konohana Lucia (Rewrite) 68 Shimakos Kagari (Rewrite) (your vote) 75 Shimakos Guardian Heroines are just that much stronger C'mon. Power levels are based on Yoshinos, not Shimakos. Though I wonder what the conversion rate between Yoshinos and Shimakos are. On a second note, that list is pretty accurate. Rewrite heroines should win by a landslide because of, well, superpowers and stuff. Shimako can use familiars but I am pretty sure Yoshino can just punt Shimako, also he's survived quite his share of dinos before going down. I think it should be something like 1 Yoshino = 2.5 Shimakos |
|
Bobjones said: Don't the characters from "Angel Beats" have superpowers? So Kanade? Then again, "Rewrite" apparently have superpowers too but I've never played that. Doesn't matter though, combat potential don't mean shit in works by Key. Sure it does, hard to get laid when you or the heroine are dead. Though it was a shame, no matter how strong Kazamatsuri Bond got, he never managed to sleep with Key. |
|
| Chihaya! |
 |
| Shizuru, followed by Lucia. Rewrite's characters are far stronger than all the others. People who are all stacking votes for Tomoyo etc clearly havent played a VN =P |
 |
Riptos said: Shizuru, followed by Lucia. Rewrite's characters are far stronger than all the others. People who are all stacking votes for Tomoyo etc clearly havent played a VN =P Tomoyo probably won't live long enough to get in range of Lucia. She'll drop dead 2 meters in front of her. |
|
Riptos said: Shizuru, followed by Lucia. Rewrite's characters are far stronger than all the others. People who are all stacking votes for Tomoyo etc clearly havent played a VN =P Agreed, every heroine in Rewrite is by far stronger than all the ones in the other games. |
| Part of Refrain Subs for Little Busters!: Refrain Recently Played/Read VNS (Most Recent to Oldest): - Da Capo - Grisaia no Kajitsu - ef - a fairy tale of the two - G-senjou no Maou - Sharin no Kuni, Himawari no Shoujo & Sharin no Kuni, Yuukyuu no Shounenshoujo (Fan Disk) - Rewrite - Hoshizora no Memoria -Wish upon a shooting star- - Clannad - Little Busters EX! |
More topics from this board
» Why doesn't the mal listing include "Sports" theme?ma1kawa11 - Sep 9, 2025 |
3 |
by Koenvis
»»
Dec 7, 2025 3:27 AM |
|
Poll: » Little Busters! Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 26, 2013 |
303 |
by YN_ON
»»
Oct 31, 2025 12:07 PM |
|
Poll: » Little Busters! Episode 14 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jan 12, 2013 |
269 |
by YN_ON
»»
Oct 27, 2025 6:11 AM |
|
Poll: » Little Busters! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Dec 22, 2012 |
112 |
by YN_ON
»»
Oct 26, 2025 12:39 AM |
|
Poll: » Little Busters! Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Yumekichi11 - Nov 24, 2012 |
289 |
by YN_ON
»»
Oct 19, 2025 9:17 AM |