Absolutely amazing show. All of the girls are adorable, and I just wanted to hug Sana until she pops. It's a shame she had to cut off the twintails.
The biggest problem with the show is its length. It really needs at least another cour to properly flesh out transition between arcs. Without adequate time, it just switches over which often leaves the plot feeling disjointed. I very much liked each incarnation, so it didn't bother me much. But I can easily see how others would be quite frustrated. It's most apparent in the original arc, where the research facility just suddenly disbands and stops chasing her. It makes sense that they would stop though. They had no intention of actually harming Sana, they just believed that the Dreams of Alice were too dangerous to live in regular society. And the Hand Girl they enlisted was more interested in forcing Sana to bring her dead husband back to life than actually following the deal. All of the characters needed much more screentime, especially Zouroku and Sanae.
All of the Dreams' powers relate to traumas they faced, and can be thought of as granted wishes. Ichijou wanted to be a hero cop like her favorite magical girl anime protagonist, the twins wanted to bind and shoot their violent father, Hand Girl longed for her husband's loving embrace, and Hatori wanted people to do what she told them. I imagine the white-haired Shota probably wanted to escape into his artwork.
Sana is your classic homunculus character learning about the world. In a sense she is both Alice and the Wonderland in 'Through the Looking Glass.' She is the girl lost in wondrous dreams and the dreams themselves. Like modern AI generative models have trouble understanding the world, she takes in information, generates assumptions, and doesn't actually understand how everything fits together. A child with limitless power but no love.
Enter Zouroku: an old-school man experienced with giving troubled girls (like Sanae) the stern but compassionate fatherly guidance they need. He's an old man and limited by his age in doing some of the grander gestures we'd like to see, but his straightforward and earnest manner always tugs at the heartstrings. He doesn't just give in to Sana's tears when she's wrong, so she can grow up to be a strong and capable girl. Their relationship is quite touching to see, and I wanted so much more of it, especially in the final episodes.
Later on Sana always complains about being frazzled. This is because she's experiencing ambivalent, conflicting emotions. She's used to feeling one way about things and can't comprehend this confusion as she develops a richer understanding of her own heart. She identifies with Hatori so strongly that their powers cancel each other out. She can't understand why she feels a range of compassionate and sorrowful emotions for the girl who (in her mind) nearly killed her surrogate father. The more this conflict comes to the fore the worse these feelings clash, until Wonderland tries to assimilate more and more of the real world in an attempt to understand it. But it can't. And so disconnected from her heart, the wishes born from her dreams no longer give Sana power, even as those dreams protect and guide her and her companions (with the exception of Ichijou who falls endlessly for some reason, probably only really to let Sanae and her grandfather be alone in the story). Fittingly, Zouroku's stern words
convince Wonderland (and by extension Sana) to accept that there are things she simply cannot understand (at least not yet). That she might actually have to wait until she's older and wiser.
10/10 in my book. I wanted more at every turn. I went through an entire range of emotions watching this. If only there were 3 seasons.
P.S.
During the kidnapping with the Hand Girl, I literally said, "Old Man Powers, Activate!" |