| People just love to hate on Toei works ( except One Piece) |
הלב שלי כבר מת |
FGAU1912 said: Casval said: People just love to hate on Toei works ( except One Piece) more lie they haye any thing that even the sligtist bit main stream im callinf ths now most underrated anime of the year Excuse me, hipster MAL users love to hate on Toei works because the animation is bad, Toei is one of the most successful studios... etc. I mean look at some of Leiji's works the best of them were animated form Toei and yet there aren't many that are rated higher than 8 here on MAL. |
הלב שלי כבר מת |
FGAU1912 said: Casval said: FGAU1912 said: Casval said: People just love to hate on Toei works ( except One Piece) more lie they haye any thing that even the sligtist bit main stream im callinf ths now most underrated anime of the year Excuse me, hipster MAL users love to hate on Toei works because the animation is bad, Toei is one of the most successful studios... etc. I mean look at some of Leiji's works the best of them were animated form Toei and yet there aren't many that are rated higher than 8 here on MAL. MAL hates mainstream anime thay hate all pairme time anime look at athe top 20 how many main stream prime time anime are there 0 They also love to hate on one of the best selling Anime genres (Mecha) and they call themself fans. |
הלב שלי כבר מת |
I am not...Excuse me if I was wrong with my prediction I "0" but I really think that it's like that (the genre part) I mean there aren't many shows that sold better than Gundam Seed,Macross F,Gundam Unicorn.. Mod Edit: Modified quote tower; please spoiler or remove old quotes. |
VudisMay 8, 2014 11:38 PM
הלב שלי כבר מת |
| At the moment its just that the main character has been made to be the most unlikeable piece of trash. Thats probably the biggest contributor to the low score this show currently has. |
| It's probably because of the protagonist, he really breaks the shounen mold. Mal users don't like genre deconstructions unless they're fluffed up with cute girls doing cute things. Furthermore, sports Manga are typically only popular here when they pander to the fujoshi audience (Free!, Kuroko) What's so wrong with Space Time? Tokusatsu Industry > Anime Industry Mod Edit: Modified quote tower; please spoiler or remove old quotes. |
VudisMay 8, 2014 11:39 PM
 |
| I think many people here on MAL dont distinguish between their liking/disliking the MC and the quality or potential of the show. Also I never got how one can rate a show after the first episode. Even when I find a first episode so horrible that it becomes an instadrop, I dont rate it. Iam just not the targetaudience in that case. |
| People don't get the humor of the MC. Plus there aren't droves of cute girls or any super powers. I'm loving it so far. Showa Japan? Enka opening? Lazy, delinquent MC? Definitely one I'm sticking with for the time being. |
FGAU1912 said: Casval said: People just love to hate on Toei works ( except One Piece) more lie they haye any thing that even the sligtist bit main stream im callinf ths now most underrated anime of the year Yep, I also think that this anime is awesome! It's so funny x) I don't see why this is so underrated |
| The start was a bit slow, the style looks very "classic" and the protagonist acts like an asshole. People tend to judge way to soon. Personally, I like this show so far. But we haven't seen much yet, so that might change. |
| It's not underrated. It's crap. There is absolutely nothing good about this show. The poisoned cake though, is the MC. I've never seen a bigger asshole as an MC ever. There is nothing likable about him, and I cannot watch something if I do not like the people in it. The humor is very crass, and is beyond shallow. "He's pissing on a door! HILLARIOUS", right? Why would I watch something if I don't give a crap about the MC? I don't give a crap what awards the manga won. One of the most acclaimed chows is Naruto... are you going to argue the quality of Naruto? |
 |
Jody32 said: In your opinion of course, to him a bad MC = a bad show. Everyone has different criteria. And he's already said the MC isn't keeping him entertained.An arsehole main character doesn't equal a bad show. Sure I can understand not liking a show because you can't relate or don't like the main character but that does not mean the show is bad, I can see this show has quite a bit of potential personally and I don't even like the main character but one thing is true though, he sure is keeping me entertained. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| the main character is a rapist that's why so understand |
leetshoe said: It's funny because if he was an attractive, psychotic rapist, this would probably be among the most popular of the season.the main character is a rapist that's why so understand |
|
FGAU1912 said: Casval said: People just love to hate on Toei works ( except One Piece) more lie they haye any thing that even the sligtist bit main stream im callinf ths now most underrated anime of the year Most underrated, and were only in the second quarter of the year. Not to shabby, not shabby at all |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
leetshoe said: the main character is a rapist that's why so understand I must have missed that scene. |
| I'm still waiting to see the real sumo action before fully judging. |
 |
| It feels as if they're just trying to hard to show how much of an idiot he is. You've even got the narrator stating straight out about how he's the baddest boy in town. Also, mc is too op as of now. |
   |
YorozuyaGinSan said: leetshoe said: It's funny because if he was an attractive, psychotic rapist, this would probably be among the most popular of the season.the main character is a rapist that's why so understand Yeah, they already tried that... TWICE: Amnesia and Diabolique Lovers. Both were utterly despised. |
|
DmonHiro said: It's not underrated. It's crap. There is absolutely nothing good about this show. The poisoned cake though, is the MC. I've never seen a bigger asshole as an MC ever. There is nothing likable about him, and I cannot watch something if I do not like the people in it. The humor is very crass, and is beyond shallow. "He's pissing on a door! HILLARIOUS", right? Why would I watch something if I don't give a crap about the MC? I don't give a crap what awards the manga won. One of the most acclaimed chows is Naruto... are you going to argue the quality of Naruto? Because of the pedigree it has. The guy that made the manga is one of the geniuses behind Ashita no Joe, and all the characters in that went through buttloads of development. I'm expecting similar stuff to happen with Matsutarou. Matsutarou has some likable qualities, too; his infatuation with his teacher is like the kind you'd see a grade-schooler have. And aren't Naruto potshots getting a bit old now? Attack on Titan's the new, hip thing that's getting loads of undeserved fame. Step up your game, son! Also, humor being crass doesn't instantly make it unfunny Mr. Highbrow. DmonHiro said: Yeah, they already tried that... TWICE: Amnesia and Diabolique Lovers. Both were utterly despised. While I don't know how well the anime did in Japan, the Diabolik Lovers visual novel is plenty popular with its target audience. I don't remember anyone getting raped in that, either. The same goes for Amnesia. And I don't get all this "MC is a rapist" stuff. He tried to kiss an unconscious woman. Calling that rape is an insult to rape victims everywhere. |
| Nothing |
| It's not underrated, it's rated fine, this show is garbage; barely made it through the first episode Everything is, 'hue he's big and still in school' 'hueehue he bullies kids' 'hue he pisses on something' so clever It's a show full of poop humor. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post and harassment. |
VudisMay 8, 2014 11:43 PM
  Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet |
DmonHiro said: You have a point, but those are both characters from popular otome games and are only despised in the western community. When the series is told from the viewpoint of the girl who is being raped, of course people will be against it. In this case, the protagonist is the rapist.YorozuyaGinSan said: leetshoe said: It's funny because if he was an attractive, psychotic rapist, this would probably be among the most popular of the season.the main character is a rapist that's why so understand Yeah, they already tried that... TWICE: Amnesia and Diabolique Lovers. Both were utterly despised. If you take rape out of the equation and have him straight up kill people he'd be even more popular. Psychotic rapists are hit and miss in the Anime community but killing is clearly less morally bankrupt, right? |
|
| Maybe because it's pacing isn't intriguing Like on the first episode where he was shown as a complete ass and no sign of reform, most people dislikes this kind of MC Only people who understand anime will know that this MC will meet it's turning point sooner or later and when he did, it will be good Well, if I have to say.. those who rated it lowly are the 14 years old teenagers There are lot's of them and actively lowing the rate of the anime they dn't like and rate highly to some off-stream anime, to make themselves feel sophisticated Personally, I find this anime quite a decent one (let's ignore the animation quality, can't help it, it's TOEI) at least until this point, I can see the anime will get better and better Although, I can never guarantee how it will turn out in the distance future. |
| "Burn the heretics" |
| I'm actually enjoying this show so far, sure the protagonist is very unlikable at the moment, but there is something called character development, so I'm sure that he'll get better. But as many stated, it's animation, art style, and the protagonist that turn a lot of people off hence the low rating, sucks that they can't look past that, but that's how life is. But is only 4 four episodes in, and I think this is going to be a long runner considering that the manga is 36 volumes, so the scores for anyone that has dropped this and rated it low will be invalid soon, so no big deal. Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
VudisMay 8, 2014 11:44 PM
 |
| OK, a lot of people seem to be defending the anime by saying it will be better later. But that's a BS defense. Why can't it be better now? I don't want to wait X amount of episodes before a series gets good, especially when other shows (Black Bullet, No Game No Life, Ping Pong) were great from episode 1. |
|
DmonHiro said: Those are seasonal anime with limited episodesOK, a lot of people seem to be defending the anime by saying it will be better later. But that's a BS defense. Why can't it be better now? I don't want to wait X amount of episodes before a series gets good, especially when other shows (Black Bullet, No Game No Life, Ping Pong) were great from episode 1. Of course they want to wrap it up as neatly as possible to boost the DVD sales While this one is a new adaptation from a classic manga I think they are going to follow the manga from a to z So, it will take some time to build the story The story ain't that bad, for me this anime is solid 7 and might improve as the time goes by |
| "Burn the heretics" |
| many people stop watching or didnt even finished episode 1.... |
 |
| When did he RAPE anyone? Is this a new tumblr definition of rape or something? Mod Edit: Removed quote of deleted post. |
VudisMay 8, 2014 11:45 PM
Jomei said: Yeah, I saw that. When did he RAPE anyone? Is this a new tumblr definition of rape or something? I think they mean, they think the MC wants to get into sensei's pants. |
| Thread cleaned. Removed spam and insults. I have left the off-topic on the first page but please try not to go off topic in a future. Stick to the discussion at hand. |
DmonHiro said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad.OK, a lot of people seem to be defending the anime by saying it will be better later. But that's a BS defense. Why can't it be better now? I don't want to wait X amount of episodes before a series gets good, especially when other shows (Black Bullet, No Game No Life, Ping Pong) were great from episode 1. |
 |
| Ping Pong is better right now, but this is improving. I was thinking about maybe dropping it but then episode 5 happened, and I found myself enjoying pretty much the whole ep. I actually am looking forward to the next one. Glad I didn't drop it yet! |
Chaos-kun said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad. lol no you can't judge something by the first episode alone. ping pong is hella realistic and it got better in the third episode. |
Chaos-kun said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad. That's funny considering if you judged Abarenbou by the first episode it's boring trash with no story. |
|
mayukachan said: Chaos-kun said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad. lol no you can't judge something by the first episode alone. ping pong is hella realistic and it got better in the third episode. You're kidding right? It was great from the first episode The moment the OP start playing, I just knew that anime is going to be great.. |
| "Burn the heretics" |
Toaki90 said: mayukachan said: Chaos-kun said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad. lol no you can't judge something by the first episode alone. ping pong is hella realistic and it got better in the third episode. You're kidding right? It was great from the first episode The moment the OP start playing, I just knew that anime is going to be great.. The first episode was good, got me interested but starting from the second episode was where I knew it would be at least an 8. The third episode I thought if it keeps this up it's 9, which so far it has. |
|
Toaki90 said: mayukachan said: Chaos-kun said: please, Abarenbou is more great than ping pong. i already drop ping pong since eps 1 cause the story was so bad. lol no you can't judge something by the first episode alone. ping pong is hella realistic and it got better in the third episode. You're kidding right? It was great from the first episode The moment the OP start playing, I just knew that anime is going to be great.. I'm not saying Pingpong wasn't great from the start. I was saying it got even better later on. After fails shows that started out with a great start like SAO, I stopped hyping things up from the first episode and looked more at the potential of the show. |
| This is definitely underrated right now. A 5.69 is really, really low by "MAL standards." I don't think it is great so far, but it is interesting and definitely deserving of a higher rating that, imo. |
 |
KingYoshi said: This is definitely underrated right now. A 5.69 is really, really low by "MAL standards." I don't think it is great so far, but it is interesting and definitely deserving of a higher rating that, imo. I can assure you it'll rise to a 6 something when it's completed. lol Meganebu! managed to go from a 5 to a 6 after it finished because of the 1/5 rule. Even Diabolik Lovers is almost a 6. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Abarenbou Rikishi!! Matsutarou Episode 4 DiscussionStark700 - Apr 26, 2014 |
21 |
by nightjasmine
»»
Oct 16, 2023 8:50 PM |
|
Poll: » Abarenbou Rikishi!! Matsutarou Episode 9 DiscussionStark700 - May 31, 2014 |
10 |
by JoseSalsa
»»
Aug 19, 2022 7:06 PM |
|
Poll: » Abarenbou Rikishi!! Matsutarou Episode 23 DiscussionStark700 - Sep 27, 2014 |
30 |
by Ashhk
»»
Nov 5, 2020 9:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Abarenbou Rikishi!! Matsutarou Episode 22 DiscussionStark700 - Sep 20, 2014 |
10 |
by Ashhk
»»
Nov 5, 2020 8:41 AM |
|
Poll: » Abarenbou Rikishi!! Matsutarou Episode 21 DiscussionStark700 - Sep 13, 2014 |
11 |
by Ashhk
»»
Nov 5, 2020 7:56 AM |