Favorite Silent Hill Game

Mar 18, 2008 5:11 PM

Sey-chan

Offline

Sep 2007

154

Mine would be SH3. I liked how it was linked to the first game, and the atmosphere was great :3

Mar 19, 2008 8:07 AM

Minimew-chan

Offline

Jan 2008

118

i like all of them but i do see what u mean about sh3 wish i could get the one on the psp

Signature Removed. Please read the General Forum Guidelines regarding signature size.

Jul 15, 2008 10:58 AM

megame8senpai

Offline

Feb 2008

105

Arisa-san said:
Mine would be SH3. I liked how it was linked to the first game, and the atmosphere was great :3

ME TOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I AM A Natsume Maya , Ryo Mimasaka, Natsume Aya, Tsubame no Simca, Sumeragi Kururu Holic.

Oct 8, 2008 12:37 PM

AnimeGamer360

Offline

Dec 2007

Silent Hill 1,2,3,origins and Silent Hill Homecoming

Oct 21, 2008 1:59 PM

MIRAcosplay

Offline

Apr 2008

Definitely "silent Hill".
I also really liked "Silent Hill 3" and "Silent Hill 2"

Oct 22, 2008 2:36 AM

Chiyo-ko

Offline

Apr 2008

875

1. SH2 - because the plot is a MASTERPIECE + the best music ever + the most interesting characters + the best creatures + really good riddles + the town design + disturbing atmosphere of silence.

2. SH4 -only because of great story of Walter Sullivan and 21 sacraments [the plot is always most important for me]

3. SH3 - the best graphic design of creatures & locatons + the most interesting locations + my personal sympathy, in spite of hardly rousing plot.

4. SH1 - the most scary game + great characters such as Lisa of Kaufmann, however, I didn't fancy the plot as much as in other games.

5. SH0 - the best riddles ever (thank you, Climax!) + interesting and sad story of Travis' family + well done town design + interesting locations (motel, sanitarium, theatre)
-SH0 makers introduced quite much of plot mistakes (in order to SH1)
-something's missing in the atmosphere of game. KONAMI...come back!

Nov 6, 2008 11:50 AM

Rebella

Offline

Oct 2008

1702

Silent Hill 3 because it was more action oriented and more innovative than the rest. In addition to the gameplay of Silent Hill3, it had the best character models with 6000 pixles in every single character. Character graphics were amazing for a game on ps2 backthen. I also liked Heather because she's one of the few strong female heroines who aren't ridiculously over powered and natural.
Silent hill 2 had the best story because it was about euthnasia. It also had the best environment.
Silent hill 4 had the best game concept because the demon exorcism quest and the way to kill demons was very addictive. The story was okay although it was a stephen King room 1417 and the movie The Ring's rip off.
Silent Hill 1 is the game that introduced me the series.

Jan 26, 2009 8:30 PM

Plastikcat

Offline

Sep 2007

116

1. SH2
2. SH1
3. SH4
4. SH3

I do not plan on playing Homecoming nor Origins

Last.FM | Play.Fire

Feb 1, 2009 1:37 PM

Chthonia

Offline

Nov 2008

186

SH2 had the best plot (one of the few games with a dedent plot) but SH3 had the best art, environments, creepiness etc... so it gets my vote.

Jul 26, 2009 1:52 AM

#10

simonfan

Offline

Oct 2008

876

SH4 and Origins

Oct 13, 2009 3:17 PM

#11

Seasonreaper

Offline

Jan 2008

2587

3 closely followed by 2. 2 has plot and music superiority whilst 3 has better creature designs, gameplay and Heather.

Oct 15, 2009 11:43 AM

#12

Spooky13

Offline

Jan 2009

3626

Silent Hill: Origins. :D

Oct 28, 2009 8:33 PM

#13

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

558998

Silent Hill 2 is definitely my favorite. Between the music, the visuals, the characters and, quite simply, everything else about the game I believe it is the purest, truest version of Silent Hill, that it really encapsulated everything that the creators meant the franchise to be. I really can't find any flaws in this game -- save for a few spotty moments in the voice acting. And the controls. Omfg, the controls make me want to kill kittens.

Silent Hill 3 is in second place (definitely the scariest of the games), with Silent Hill and Silent Hill 4 in a tie for third.

I try to ignore the existence of Origins and Homecoming. Americans really can't help but screw everything up when they get their hands on some foreign franchise. I mean, Origins wasn't terrible -- they managed to mostly stick to the overall message and feeling of the previous games -- but Homecoming killed my hope that any more worthwhile Silent Hill games will be made.

Nov 28, 2009 11:55 AM

#14

alav5112021

Offline

Jul 2008

1: SH4
2: SH
3: SH2
4: SH3

Dec 15, 2009 10:15 PM

#15

Karubi

Offline

Oct 2008

1560

Silent Hill 3, Silent Hill, Silent Hill 2.

Silent Hill 4 was awful imo.

I have yet to play Origins or Homecoming, can't wait to get Shattered Memories for the PS2 though.

Jan 3, 2010 11:25 AM

#16

Spooky13

Offline

Jan 2009

3626

Have to say, Silent Hill: Shattered Memories was great. haha.

Spooky13Jun 28, 2010 7:23 AM

Jan 3, 2010 11:46 AM

#17

Eridanus

Offline

Apr 2008

372

My choice would be:

no1 - Silent Hill 2 Epic game (tics all the boxes and more)

no2 - Silent hill 3 Heather (thats all u need^^)
no3 - Silent hill 1 Classic (its first and its awesome)
no4 - Silent hill 5 Awesome game (SH series is back from the dead)

Very long and deep space of nothingness

no5 - Silent hill 4 HUH??? WHAT??? (still a good game but at times a bit dodgy)

Jan 3, 2010 8:00 PM

#18

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

558998

Yasha_Hikari said:
I try to ignore the existence of Origins and Homecoming. Americans really can't help but screw everything up when they get their hands on some foreign franchise. I mean, Origins wasn't terrible -- they managed to mostly stick to the overall message and feeling of the previous games -- but Homecoming killed my hope that any more worthwhile Silent Hill games will be made.

Looks like I'll be retracting that last sentence. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories is incredibly awesome and definitely tied with Silent Hill 3 for second place in my rankings of Silent Hill games. I just marathoned it seven times in the past three days. So, so good.

Jan 18, 2010 11:40 AM

#19

Pheefa

Offline

Aug 2009

1092

SH2 was the most emotional for me, and the most scary by far. Beautiful story, beautiful soundtrack, beautiful PYRAMID HEAD =D

SH3 comes in a close second. Heather was a brilliant protagonist.

Looking forward to playing Shattered Memories when it's out here in the UK. I've only seen the trailer so far and I LOL'd at 'I'm Dahlia'

頭脳は子供、見た目は大人！ ƪ(˘⌣˘)ʃ

Sep 30, 2012 7:12 AM

#20

IkezawaHanako

Offline

May 2012

Personally, I prefered SH2. The plot was amazing and amazing protagonist. I could really connect with James' thoughts at times. Very touching. As in most SH games, the monsters were very symbolic and gave the plot a great, final touch. Also, the soundtrack was amazing.

Can you face your fears?

Dec 11, 2012 2:00 PM

#21

protag

Offline

Jan 2012

Wow I'm not sure if I can really choose my favourite, because they are all amazing games and I just askasdf-

SH2 gets the first place, I think. I absolutely loved the story and characters, and also, as someone mentioned before, I too agree that this is the most accurate depiction of Silent Hill that the creators wanted to show us. The symbolism is also great, along with creatures (and they merged together perfectly). Don't even get me started about the soundtrack okay.

The second one would be SH3. Mainly because of Heather. Definitely my fav SH protagonist. Oh, and Vincent. Oh Vincent.
The characters were the strongest part of the game for me. And Melissa Williamson.

And another second place goes to SH1 aka the freaking scariest game on earth. I can't even explain. I loved the mini sub-plot that was dealing with White Claudia, the little mindfucking things, like the elevator in the hospital and all of this brilliant stuff.

No third place sorry.

See All Discussions

» What do you think of the Movie? Pheefa - Jan 18, 2010	5	by protag »» Apr 23, 2012 6:34 AM
Poll: » Favorite Character Midori-tan - Nov 6, 2008	9	by fluffy_shem »» Mar 21, 2011 12:11 PM
» Silent hill 6? thepapercut - Oct 21, 2009	4	by Midori-tan »» Jun 26, 2010 2:37 PM
» Silent Hill 2 The Movie ANNOUNCED Eridanus - Jan 20, 2010	2	by Eko »» Jun 20, 2010 10:30 AM
Poll: » Favorite Soundtrack Plastikcat - Feb 12, 2009	5	by Pheefa »» Jan 18, 2010 11:46 AM

Favorite Silent Hill Game

More topics from this board

» What do you think of the Movie?

Poll: » Favorite Character

» Silent hill 6?

» Silent Hill 2 The Movie ANNOUNCED

Poll: » Favorite Soundtrack

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters