Oct 19, 2026
Apothecary Diaries is a mixed story. At its best it's a passionate fictional period-piece that immerses itself in societal dynamics, hidden politics and underlying tension. But at its worst, and it really does stay here for a while, it follows flat characters embroiled in mysteries that are beyond the scope of these characters to solve. Maomao and Jinshi really drag what could've been a great story down to a slog, which only gets redeemed by other characters
STORY:
There are two places the 40 Chapter mark can be split into, which is also where the Anime's season 1 ends. The inner court and the outer court. The
...
inner court which makes up 20 chapters is great, in that it sets up this conspiracy of consorts being poisoned and the emperor's heirs dying, which pushes our MC Maomao to solve the case and save the dynasty. Through this arc we see interesting characters, the inner workings of the society displayed and good mysteries. However, after Maomao is brought to the outer court is where the story nosedives. The mysteries become a lot more random, less in-depth and exceed what knowledge Maomao should have. The story also reverts from its display of society to drag on long exposition dumps that make no sense within the character's perspective. This drags on for 15 chapters, before we finally take a peek into more Lakan and his relationship with Maomao, which is definitely the best part of this arc. There isn't much I can say without spoilers due to the nature of the story relying on mysteries, but the problems of the story are laid bare when we are removed from the exploration on society and focus on the boring characters.
CHARACTERS:
Maomao is one of the most bland and inoffensive protagonists, so much so that she becomes offensive to me, similar to Asta from Black Clover or Madoka from Madoka Magica. The best way to explain Maomao is that she's the Deus Ex Machina keeping the entire empire afloat. Without her, the incompetency of the dynasty would cause it to fall, due to her immense, inexplicable knowledge at the age of 18 that no one else has. Even though she's an Apothecary her knowledge somehow extends to agriculture, metallurgy, inner politics and the duties of a consort. And although she is emotionally distant and vapid, both in relationships and with her own feelings, people fall for her like nothing. Every flaw she has (lack of interest in studying, apathy) is compensated for by people around her with no real reason. The only time her apathy is subverted is when she gets ingredients for her medicine or when someone infuriates her. With her enjoyment with seeing ingredients, it's funny the first time but after it's done to death for 40 chapters it feels like the author is just jingling keys in front of you.
This lauding for her comes at the cost of every other character. The women are either depicted as irrationally conservative, humble housewives with no ambition or lusty women submitting to patriarchal expectations but sexily. Basically, in an attempt to write a "good" woman, the writer flips the trapdoor under every other woman. I understand the story is a "period piece," but the writing of other women is shallow. Even the consorts are just written with footnotes of 3 adjectives describing them. They don't have any intrigue after you understand all that.
Jinshi is... I don't even know. The story throws crumbs of characterisation for him, but the entire picture is that he's infatuated with Maomao for 0 reason. He does occassionally have vulnerability or weakness, but these are one-off moments that get navigated through off-page. The story tries to say he's a eunuch through Maomao's perspective but it simply makes 0 sense, he's a 6 foot chiseled man with abs, no Eunuch looks like that, and Maomao would know this.
Both of these characters serve as our first-person narrators, and they're both uninteresting narrators. Maomao's apathy means the world is seen through extreme cynicism, which means there's little room for interpretation and it is spoken moreso as exposition. Jinshi has a bit more of an introspective emotional narrative, but he too sometimes spirals into exposition dumps.
And this blandness applies to most side characters. They're very weak and only defined by one trait. Muscular, docile, childish, sexy. That's about it. The character writing is very weak in this story. Maomao sometimes "erupts" at these characters, which means the story shades her face and makes her talk scarily even though she has not a bone of intimidation in her body. It just comes off as funny to me, it's like expecting Gon to be what he was to Neferpitou without any context.
CONCLUSION:
It's a good story that's weighed down by poorly written mysteries and characters. The main characters Maomao and Jinshi are unable to offer any interesting perspective on the world with their first-person views, and end up just regurgitating information. If you like the period-piece setting and don't mind the extreme praise Maomao gets in the story, you'll like it just fine.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all