Feb 15, 2026
It's been about three months since I finished this. I think this is enough to cool down and write this review with a calm head (and not a burning ass).
First 5 volumes was good: pure romance, that's it.
Actually, first 4. The 5th (festival arc) has already begun to deviate from the initially set mood and tone of narrative towards hackneyed 'interpersonal conflicts' but...
at first time it can be forgiven.
Unfortunately in later volumes author gone bad and begun reuse that again and again and again with different characters
and this can no longer be forgiven.
My guess is that all these interpersonal conflicts and heightened drama are
...
the result of the editor's influence.
Narration
First 4 vols (let it call 'prearc chapters') are fragmented and nonlinear. i.e. each chapter = one day of life, one microsituation after school,
and that 'previous chapter' situation is not connected in any way and do not influence future one.
Moreover, they are not in chronological order:
it could be summer for example, next chapter it's winter already, next one - autumn or even summer again. That mixing happens many times and make you lose time sense. It's like some sort of weird timeloop. According to plot, our heroes are 2th grade of high school. That mean they have 1.5-2 more years of school left. But according to season change... well looks like they have been studying for 4-5 years already.
'Arc chapters' (later vols) become linear ofc.
If I should rate, then the first 4 vols would be 8,
but further it rapidly loses points cuz selfrepeat and mark time.
/Here is memo in my cheatnote: "First 4 vols was good but then f***ed up in three different ways"
Unfortunately, after three months I forgot what I meant by that ololol/
Characters
Urabe changes a bit too. From being initially "mysterious" she turned... into less mysterious and more... uhm, predatory? Have no idea how to describe it. Even her appearance changes. And again, all this happens somewhere 5-6th vol.
But Tsubaki... oho, that's another story. Throughout the entire manga he does not change at all. What a will-less wimp he was at the beginning, and he remains so at the end. No progress, no development.
Probably it's a bad manner to refer to third-party work when you write review, but...
For example, in 'Ijiranaide, Naga-san' protagonist changes. And more important, those changes are more interior driven than exterior, i.e. he wants to change.
But Tsubaki... he is a maximum slave. Beckon him and he will follow (into troubles. Then does not learn any lessons and can be drawn into another troubles again). Pathetic. No will, no 'inner core' and personal growth til the end.
Ending
On the one hand, it can't be left unmentioned, but on the other, how can I do it without spoiling it? Ok, let's say:
this is in spirit 'how to flush down 10 years of work'.
Great disappointment.
And personally for author (ofc he never see this): if you have no balls to make proper ending, then, maybe, you should stop being mangaka at all?
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all