Back to KonomiHasumi's Profile KonomiHasumi's Profile

Writing my very first review because I couldn’t stand seeing this manga left with only a negative one. T_T

Story

I read Kirarin☆Revolution multiple times when I was within its intended age group (like 13 years ago), and I absolutely loved it. It was my very first manga, which gives it a special place in my heart, but nostalgia alone isn’t what makes it work. Yes, it is full of classic shoujo clichés, but that’s also part of its charm (much like any other shoujo). The story is not focused on realism, but on growth, effort, and believing in your dreams.

Kirari starts knowing absolutely nothing about the ... idol world, but after falling in love with an idol, she becomes determined to enter that world herself. She is a complete disaster at first: she can’t sing or act, and even simple things like baking or sewing go hilariously wrong... but she works tirelessly to learn everything from scratch. Her determination, attitude, and natural brightness show that she has the potential to shine. The story reinforces that dreams come true only when you give your all, that luck and opportunities favor those who work for them, and that good things happen when you remain genuine and kind, even when it's hard.

Characters/Relationships

Kirari’s journey is about resilience, kindness, and emotional growth in a highly competitive industry. She faces several rivals who often use underhanded tactics, but Kirari never stoops to their level. Instead, she overcomes them through honest competition, creativity, positive thinking, and unwavering dedication. While some are completely overwhelmed by this, others (llike Fubuki) eventually come to respect her after recognizing her genuine effort, talent, and perseverance, becoming more like “friendly rivals.”

Hiroto’s "colder and harsher" side of his tsundere personality often pushes Kirari to face reality, fueling a healthy determination that helps her work harder and fight for her goals. His bluntness can sometimes hurt or be frustrating, but it frequently serves as a grounding force. In contrast, Seiji plays a supportive role: consistently kind, gentle, and emotionally aware of what’s happening around him. He offers comfort and stability, and ultimately helps both Kirari and Hiroto realize their feelings for each other. This was never a true love triangle, as Kirari’s feelings for Seiji were more idealized than romantic. Over the course of the story, she genuinely falls in love with Hiroto and gradually comes to understand her true feelings.

Erina, Kirari’s first rival, is a stereotypical jealous character whose “cute and innocent” façade hides manipulative behavior, which can be uncomfortable but is intentional. The reader sees through her act, while fans in the story (and even Kirari, who considers her a friend) do not. This reflects how real-life idols can mask unpleasant behavior behind a perfect public image. Though sometimes cringeworthy, her role reinforces the story’s commentary on appearances, competition, and authenticity. It's a pattern also seen with many of Kirari’s other rivals, who project calm, friendly or mature images while being much harsher/evil behind the scenes.

Art

The art style of Kirarin☆Revolution reflects the era in which the manga was released, with its large shoujo eyes, expressive faces, and soft, flowing lines. This style perfectly matches the lighthearted, optimistic tone of the story and appeals strongly to its younger/girly audience. While not hyper-detailed, the artwork is incredibly charming. The outfits, in particular, are a standout feature: from Kirari’s cute costumes to the flamboyant and playful idol stage outfits, each design adds personality and energy to the scenes, reflecting both the fashion trends of the time and the imaginative, whimsical world of japanese idols.

As an artist myself, I find this style deeply inspiring; not only for its expressiveness and charm, but also for the way it captures emotion, the vibrant energy of the idol world, its overall cuteness, and how perfectly it matches Kirari’s bright and cheerful personality. Even today, the art maintains a nostalgic appeal that makes it a joy to revisit!

Final Thoughts

While intended for a younger audience, this manga still offers enough emotional nuance and character development, with a clear structure and well-balanced pacing. The manga is superior to its anime adaptation, even though the anime was a major success. Kirarin☆Revolution may not appeal to readers seeking realism, darker themes, or modern aesthetics, but when considered in the context of its lighthearted tone, its intended audience, and the era in which it was released, it sure delivers a warm and meaningful story about kindness, perseverance, and chasing your dreams. The only reason I didn’t give it a perfect score is that I would have loved to see more of the romantic moments and the development of the relationship between Kirari and Hiroto. The pacing felt a bit rushed from the moment they clearly realized their feelings to the beginning of their relationship and then to the story’s conclusion. I enjoyed it so much that I would have happily read even more if the story had continued tho!