- Last OnlineToday, 5:59 AM
- GenderMale
- BirthdayJul 3, 2001
- JoinedNov 9, 2020
MAL×entine My MALentine Story
RSS Feeds
|
Sep 4, 2025
I regret starting this manga, the first two volume are great and sweet, like 7/10 romance but the following is appalling and I just want to forget about this manga and this artist art forever.
The first two volume are really great (7/10) a sweet dynamic between the 2 characters, the drawings are great and the story is really pleasant to follow. Feels like your usual cliche romance with a kind of popular teasing girl with the protagonist.
But for the following part, it goes from sweet and relative innocence to almost porn with elementary looking like people... If you want more information, check the review by
...
HyperlinkBlocked (it got spoiler warning).
The art is great, the autor is a really good artist, wich makes the art even more appalling...
But if you're into his hentai loli doujinshi this show will make you like sasha mabe a little bit more and hope for salvation for her.
Reviewer’s Rating: 1
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Dec 18, 2023
A cool plot and art style, a rush end that leave a bitter taste to the overall story !
Overall : 7/10
Read it if you like the art style and basic plot but be aware that the end is rush and abrupt !
Story plot : 6/10
The plot is cool and interesting and the messages are great. But I didn't appreciate when it started to be a sort of harem... But I still want more of it !
Art : 8/10 :
Really liked the art style of the author, cool drawing and he gives the character some great style !
...
Enjoyement : 7/10
I enjoy the story even if the last chapters were feeling rushed...
Ending : 3/10
Forced and rush, real disappointing, the story could have been clearly better. So much potential in here that will never see. At least this rush ending still make some sense.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Oct 22, 2023
I binge read this manga in 2 days. So, my experience of it is not the same as the ones who read it weekly.
Overall, I appreciate this manga, but I can see all his flaws. The author lost his way at a part of time but there are still really good moments, the end of the Gal-4 eyes relationship and the end of the baseball guy story. I can say that this 2-side story were better than the end of the MC story.
This manga have flaws but I still enjoy it enough to make this review to not forget it !
Characters : 6/10
MC : you
...
think he grows but the mangaka don't think so. And that is how you end up with this ending to prove that yeah, the MC had evolved from chapter 1.
FMC : I don't really appreciate her and she has very little character evolving.
Gal Kanou is a yes and well-done characters with good development.
4 eyes girl : At a moment in the manga the mangaka thought of doing of her not just a classic girl but a girl with a superiority complex but it's just like for 1 chapter and doesn't go anywhere after that. But because of that I really do not appreciate her.
The friends along the way are very cool, especially Takahashi. Very good part with his side story !
Story : First part 7/10 Second part MC 6/10 Second part Manga 7/10
The manga trait homosexuality I think pretty well. There is a side story with a character who is gay and it's well made, I think.
For me this manga has for me 2 endings. There is a first end at the end of the school trip (around chapter 60) and the classic end.
And after the first ending there is 2 different plots going on. The MC plot and the manga plot. Two different things and I kind of prefer the second one (prefer the characters there). It's kind of the first time that I feel this much that there is 2 story going on and they don't even meet up at the end. Not even in the chapter bonus (106.5 omake).
The first part is okay quite well done but the school trip as too much things going on that's where there is one of the best scenes even if this scene made me dislike the MC.
The final ending gives a lot of critics when it came out. But when you binge read it it’s kind of make sense. But even if it makes sense it makes you feel conflicted feeling and I don’t think the bonus chapter really help his case that much… But I still enjoy the story before this ending.
This show still made me tear up a little bit on the last arc (because of the gal and glasses girl chap 102). And my heart goes pounding sometimes but still very little for a manga this long...
And at a part in the manga, I really hate the MC and after that the FMC.
Art : 7/10
I love gals and I appreciate how he drew them. It's more realistic to the classic gal mode than the new one so it's cool to see it !
The art style is kind of normal, like there isn't many extravagant scene but there are still some pages that marked me for the composing and how pretty they were. (chap 102 page 14)
Enjoyment : 8/10
I still had a good time reading it and I would love to read it again with just the best part (gal part and baseball part) or with a little bit more satisfying ending.
In the end 7/10, a mid-manga that I enjoy more than I thought I would !
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Sep 21, 2022
If you want to watch a good isekai pass your way, if you want to get a boner while watching an anime you are at the right place !
If it was a hentai that would have been a very good one, but it's just an anime so it's not really great.
The animation is quite poor but the style is great with cool color ans the story is ok. As an anime it is a bad isekai, it's make us dream of world developpement but with more than quarter per episode fill with sex, there is quite none in the end.
The poster of the anime make
...
us dream of multiple girl in the harem, but finally we only see one for 11 episode so it is a false promise.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jun 22, 2022
I have watch every isekai or anime with strong MC I can found. This one is the worst one.
The story is just bad, but not as bad as the character... The main character is OK, I can tolerate him but the side characters are bad.
The art is bad, I don't count the number of shot with no movement or bad drawing...
The only people who will give this anime good points have not go after the 4 episode. I prefere to recommand the daily life of the immortal king, or the irregular at magic highschool, or the misfit of the demon king. Much greater anime !
Reviewer’s Rating: 1
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|