- Last OnlineToday, 3:39 AM
- GenderMale
- BirthdayFeb 6, 1999
- LocationPorto
- JoinedMar 16, 2019
RSS Feeds
|
Nov 15, 2026
Verdict: 7.7/10
Let me start with what works, because there's a lot of it. The cast is genuinely well-built: distinct, memorable, likeable, and easy to watch interact. The animation surprised me with its quality, beauty, and attention to detail. The voice acting is excellent across the board. The balance between serious moments and comedic pauses keeps things from going monotone, and the characters feel like real friends who behave like friends naturally. Up until around episode 8, I was having a genuinely good time.
My core problem is structural, not tonal. I don't believe genre excuses anything. Every genre can produce great stories or mediocre ones, and
...
plenty of small, modest anime deliver exactly what they promise in a satisfying way. I enjoy those. My issue with Makeine is that it makes a clear promise, romance drama, invests real money and craft into selling that promise, and then fails to deliver on the demanding half of it. Drama is an unforgiving genre. A mediocre shounen can coast on momentum and spectacle; a mediocre drama exposes itself immediately, because the entire product is the quality of its conflict.
And the conflict here has no stakes. At no point does Kazuhiko risk losing anything. The heroines have already lost, which is fine as a premise, but nothing ever threatens him, so there's no engine driving tension. He seems to act automatically according to his personality rather than through conscious, difficult choices. To be fair, I actually admire how he functions as support through presence and availability rather than as a protagonist who solves everything for everyone else. It gives the other characters genuine agency: you sense they'd handle their problems alone too, just less effectively. That's realistic and mature writing. But admiration for his role doesn't fix the fact that the plot never puts him under pressure.
This connects to my second complaint: everyone welcomes Kazuhiko almost automatically. The heroines make some sense, since he validates their insecurities directly. But the wider cast holds him in such high esteem without him doing anything that would justify it from their perspective. Either this should develop more slowly, or the path to it should involve friction and cost. That's precisely where Oregairu handles the same foundation better. Hachiman makes deliberate choices that hurt him in order to protect what he values, generating real conflicts with people who gradually come to understand and accept him, not out of sudden affection, but out of earned respect. Look at Hayama: the "perfect" opposite of Hachiman who develops genuine mutual regard for him. Nobody in Makeine pays a price like that.
Which brings me to the rationality problem. Apart from a few exceptions, every teenager in this show behaves like a composed adult who sits down to talk things through. Real adolescents are messier, more emotional, more prone to acting badly. If Kazuhiko were written as the outlier because of this, his difference could drive change through direct interaction. Instead, he mostly listens and offers minimal assistance, while everyone else appears ready to do exactly what they end up doing anyway. With so few genuine misunderstandings and so few people carried away by emotion, problems feel banal. You know from the first scene that everything will resolve optimally.
The Komari arc crystallizes all of this. Making a girl with zero social capacity the president of a club is illogical on its face. People who care about her emotional wellbeing shouldn't subject her to a stressful role she's unfit for, and asking Kazuhiko to be VP when the reverse made far more sense from the start reads as a contrivance to force proximity. Worse, the subplot gets discarded within the same episode that introduces it. Her meltdown when he reaches out also contradicts her established psychology: if she fears abandonment, and Kazuhiko is the one person always present at the literature club, she should cling closer, not push him away. Self-sabotage as a defense mechanism is a valid choice, but the anime never dramatizes that internal conflict except when the plot requires it. And after the festival arc already taught both characters to rely on others, repeating the exact same moral one episode later with the club meeting feels redundant. This is where my dislike of her solidified: spoiled, with outbursts that serve the script rather than the character.
All of this feeds the sensation that haunts the second half: an ouroboros. Slice of life can prioritize daily routine and psychological growth over plot, but usually you still understand why characters face what they face and where they're heading. Here, despite progression, the story doesn't advance. It circles the same characters, problems, and feelings, leaving them static. Traumas get created and overcome, yet nobody undergoes a fundamental, perceptible change. That's when watching becomes exhausting rather than pleasant, and finishing becomes about finishing.
There's also a consistency issue with Kazuhiko himself. He's introduced as antisocial and avoidant, then makes friends quickly and easily, and acts correctly with a level head almost constantly, except whenever the story needs conflict or emotional weight. The final episode adds little and plays like an OVA.
I want to be precise about what I'm condemning, because it isn't flawfulness itself. Mirai Nikki, Arifureta, and Hajimete no Gal are full of holes and inconsistencies, and I still enjoyed them, because they know what they are and commit to it. The greatest sin in storytelling, for me, is trying to be something you aren't while neglecting to strengthen what you already do well. Around episode 8, that's exactly what happens here: the strong points get sidelined to force in worse character development and weaker drama. The feeling of wasted time is the clearest indicator of a story that stopped earning your attention.
It remains fun to watch in moderation, if you have nothing better queued up. But binge-watching reveals the seams, and there's nothing here demanding investment. There are better slice of life titles, better romances, and better comedies. A good anime that dies on the beach before becoming excellent, and definitively far from any masterpiece.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Oct 28, 2026
While Cyberpunk: Edgerunners 2 maintains the high-quality animation and stylish direction of Studio Trigger, it ultimately collapses under the weight of its own narrative confusion. It feels less like a sequel and more like a misunderstanding of what made the first season a masterpiece. The result is a show that looks incredible but fails to capture the soul of Night City or the hearts of its characters.
The Narrative Fragmentation The most glaring issue is the lack of a cohesive protagonist. By splitting the focus between four distinct leads—King, Talia, D, and Roman—the series dilutes its emotional impact. In Season 1, we had one clear thread
...
(David’s rise and fall) that allowed us to deeply connect with his motivations. Here, the constant switching between POVs prevents any meaningful attachment. We never spend enough time with any character to care about their struggles, leading to a sense of detachment where I found myself indifferent to their fates. The pacing suffers immensely as a result; episodes feel sluggish yet rushed, lacking the urgent momentum that drove the first season. Watching at 1.5x or even 2x speed actually improved the experience, which is a damning indictment of the editing and pacing choices.
Characterization Failures: With few exceptions, the new cast is uninteresting and poorly written.
King ("Weak"): He is arguably the biggest disappointment. Portrayed as a legendary mercenary, he acts with zero proactivity or tactical awareness. His incompetence is frustrating rather than tragic. The scene where he struggles with the recoil of his iconic weapon only to handle it perfectly in the next is not just bad writing; it breaks immersion completely. His apathy doesn’t read as trauma—it reads as lazy characterization. He should have been a competent veteran overwhelmed by Arasaka’s overwhelming force, not a clumsy amateur who constantly fails due to plot-induced stupidity.
Talia: While her design stands out, she lacks agency. She is largely a plot device—a "damsel in distress" whose suffering happens to her rather than being driven by her own choices.
D & Capri: Their relationship feels forced and unearned. They develop deep bonds without sharing significant hardships or meaningful interactions. D’s obsession with Capri feels sudden and unjustified, turning him into a passive follower rather than a proactive protagonist. Capri herself is a conceptually interesting idea ruined by inconsistent lore application; her powers defy the established rules of digital constructs, feeling more like generic anime superpowers than Cyberpunk tech.
Lore Inconsistencies and World-Building The writers seem to misunderstand the core tenets of the Cyberpunk universe.
Arasaka/Kang Tao Incompetence: Megacorporations are supposed to be terrifying, omnipotent entities capable of crushing nations. Here, they are portrayed as bumbling villains who let protagonists walk away from secure facilities. This nerfs the stakes entirely. If Arasaka can be defeated by a ragtag group of incompetent edgerunners, why do they rule the world?
Cyberpsychosis: The show reduces this complex condition to a simple side effect of implants. The original game and S1 treated it as a psychological breakdown exacerbated by societal pressure and rapid augmentation. Here, it’s random and shallow.
Night City: The city itself feels dead. Gone is the vibrant, oppressive atmosphere and the environmental storytelling that made Night City a character in itself. This version feels like a generic sci-fi backdrop where scenes happen, rather than a living, breathing dystopia.
Tone and Writing Quality The tone has shifted drastically from the satirical, gritty tragedy of S1 to something lighter and more comedic. Humor in Cyberpunk works best when it highlights the absurdity of capitalism or provides sharp contrast to violence. Here, the jokes feel tonally dissonant, undermining the stakes. The writing seems to prioritize trying to force an emotional reaction rather than earning it through good storytelling. The villain is predictable (the husband), and the plot twists are telegraphed miles away.
Conclusion: Edgerunners 2 is a fast-food adaptation of its predecessor. It hits the visual notes but misses every emotional and intellectual beat. The action sequences are well-animated, and the soundtrack has moments, but these cannot save a script that wastes its potential. The ending, attempting to be hopeful, feels unearned in a universe defined by inevitable tragedy. It is a disappointing, mediocre sequel that serves only to remind us how brilliant the first season truly was.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Oct 19, 2026
I am dropping The Beginning After the End anime after Episode 6. While I initially appreciated the premise of a cold, calculating King reincarnated into a child’s body, the execution of this adaptation has left me with a sense of disjointed frustration. The core issue is not just technical, but narrative: the anime struggles to reconcile the protagonist’s adult intellect with his childish physiology, resulting in a character who feels less like a complex individual and more like two separate entities forced into one frame.
This dissonance is most glaring in Arthur’s behavior. He acts with the emotional volatility of a toddler—frequent crying, clinging to Sylvie,
...
and calling her "Grandma" after only a few days of interaction—while his internal monologue remains that of a ruthless, pragmatic monarch. This creates a jarring uncanny valley effect. In contrast, look at Mushoku Tensei; Rudeus Greyrat rarely cries as a child precisely because he is an adult soul, making his moments of vulnerability impactful because they are earned and deliberate. Arthur’s constant weeping, juxtaposed with his "War King" internal voice, feels unearned and inconsistent. By Episode 3, his mindset shifts from "kill all enemies" to a protective, emotional stance without any proper narrative construction. This abrupt change strips his character of the rigidity and maturity one would expect from someone who has survived centuries of betrayal and danger.
The pacing exacerbates these character flaws. The anime rushes through events in a desperate attempt to create emotional weight, but without sufficient character development, those emotions fall flat. For instance, Arthur’s bond with Sylvie feels shallow because we haven’t spent enough time with them to understand the depth of that connection. Similarly, his reaction to being separated from his parents is nonsensical. He shows almost no immediate distress once he knows they are safe, and his subsequent guilt over "not being happy" they see him again feels like forced angst. Psychologically, a reincarnated King would likely be more concerned with the passage of time or survival than parental approval. This guilt feels like a writing crutch intended to generate sympathy, but instead, it comes across as disconnected from Arthur’s established personality. Even his indifference to Sylvie’s apparent death, despite witnessing the attack, lacks the emotional resonance it should have, making his reactions feel robotic rather than human.
Combat and intelligence are other areas where the adaptation fails to do justice to the source material. Arthur is supposed to be a tactical genius, yet when facing bandits who kidnapped Tessa, he claims to have only one day of preparation but forms no real strategy other than to attack head-on. A King with centuries of warfare experience would mitigate his physical weakness as a four-year-old through traps, precision, or psychological warfare, not brute force. The fact that he wins these fights without displaying any clear tactical superiority makes his victories feel unearned and his competence questionable. It undermines the very premise of his reincarnation: that his mind is his greatest weapon.
On a technical level, the production quality does not help. The animation is largely stiff, relying heavily on static images with slight zooms or effects to simulate movement. This "limited animation" style fails to capture the dynamism of the fights, making them feel weightless. The art style for the elves also bears a striking resemblance to the "Capsule Corp" designs from Dragon Ball, which may distract viewers. Furthermore, the opening theme feels amateurish, resembling a teenage cover of bands like Linkin Park or Bring Me The Horizon, lacking the epic, mature tone that the story strives for.
Ultimately, these issues make me suspicious that the problems I am seeing in the anime are not inherent to the story, but are rather failures of adaptation. The general consensus is that the Manhwa is significantly superior, and my experience so far supports this. The Manhwa allows for the slow, nuanced development of Arthur’s internal conflict, the gradual building of his relationships with Sylvie and his family, and the tactical clarity of his combat. The anime’s rush to plot points strips away the psychological depth that makes the character compelling. Because the anime fails to justify Arthur’s emotional shifts or his tactical prowess, I believe the source material is the only way to truly experience the story as intended. I am dropping the anime to start reading the Manhwa, where I hope to find the consistency and depth that this adaptation has so far failed to provide.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Oct 14, 2026
Re:Zero—Starting Life in Another World—is a series that is fundamentally contradictory in its structure. It attempts to combine the Isekai Fantasy tropes with the psychological horror tone, but these two genres are at odds with each other. Character designs, voice acting, and the tension of individual scenes are high quality, but the architecture of the narrative is the problem. This is a review of why the story is not up to its potential, not for lack of trying, but for poor choices in pacing, character development, and plot connectivity.
1. The Genre Clash: Fantasy vs. Horror The show uses isekai tropes (summoning, cheat abilities, and fantasy
...
races) that set viewers up for a story of mastery and progression. But the narrative logic is that of a tragedy/horror, where agency is punished and suffering is the only constant.
The Problem: This creates tonal friction. A down-to-earth or low-fantasy setting would have better served the psychological realism. The fantasy elements feel haphazard, like they’re there for traps rather than world-building.
2. Protagonist Stagnation and the “Self-Insert” Problem Subaru Natsuki is less a character in his own right and more an authorial proxy. This creates several problems:
No Growth: Subaru has not grown intellectually or tactically in any meaningful way despite the one-year time skip. He never studies magic theory, political structures, or the history of the world. His reliance on pure improvisation and "willpower" feels unearned when compared to protagonists like Rudeus (Mushoku Tensei) or Shiroe (Log Horizon).
Visual Stagnation: Subaru wearing the same tracksuit a year after being transported to a fantasy world indicates the story is more concerned with the audience’s identification than immersion.
Static Trajectory: Subaru’s suffering is emphasized, but rarely does it lead to a fundamental change in his behavior. He remains emotionally reactive, rather than growing into a resilient leader.
3. Weak Plot Connectivity Unlike Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood, where every clue is tied into a grand, architectural design, Re:Zero’s plot is episodic.
No Ramifications: Major catastrophic events (the village massacre, the Sanctuary trial) are mentioned in dialog but do not fundamentally alter the cast’s behavior or the state of the world.
Reactive Storytelling: The plot often feels like “things happen so Subaru can suffer” rather than a logical unfolding of cause and effect. The big picture mysteries are revealed early on, and the later seasons are about consequences that feel thin.
4. Universal Trauma and Emotional Flattening Everyone in Re:Zero is broken, traumatized, and emotionally underdeveloped, main characters included.
Loss of Contrast: In the absence of “composed” characters (like Jiraiya or Kakashi in Naruto) to act as a baseline of stability, Subaru’s empathy suffers by comparison. When everyone is yelling, no one is hearing.
Stunted Older Characters: Powerful characters like Roswaal and Reinhard are emotionally immature for their age, acting out of petulance or obsession rather than wisdom. This makes the world less real and more like a playground for drama.
5. Rem's removal: Rem's fate is just a plot device to spur Subaru's growth. Her absence hardly affects his daily psychology after Season 2.
Instrumental Grief: Rem was his defining wound. His later composure, and no change in behavior, is a stretch. The story doesn't incorporate her loss into his permanent identity, using her as a plot device rather than an enduring influence.
Suggested Narrative Fix The story is wasted in its execution. A better structure would be:
Treat the Curse as an Addiction: Show Subaru’s desensitization to pain and life, making him emotionally distant, not just “tough.”
Implement Hard Limits: Design situations where resetting is not possible, compelling Subaru to depend on allies and raising the stakes without requiring power-ups.
Motivation Changes: Goals from self-preservation and guilt to love. Let there be reflection between crises.
Conclusion Re: Zero is a series of good scenes tied together with a weak narrative spine. It's a case of "good components, bad architecture." The author is good at dialogue and atmosphere but not at macro-structure. If you’re the type of person who cares about earned competence, architectural plotting, and emotional contrast, then Re:Zero is probably going to be a frustrating experience no matter how well it’s produced.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 13, 2026
Such a disappointing anime; the characters are bland and 1-dimensional, the war apparently doesn't affect the world that much, and there aren't any stakes as nobody is dying (and probably won't if we base the first fight in the 1st ep). The protagonists don't have chemistry except for having exactly the same tastes in everything. The war is just a background that the characters don't appear to have any real emotions besides making an angry face here and there.
How does it have a score so high? I have no idea; I guess people like Kirito-wannabe protagonists with no personality or real drive besides scoring girls
...
and having fights with no real stakes or objectiveness. Many interesting ideas that don't get developed...
Reviewer’s Rating: 3
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 13, 2026
What a disappointment this anime is; the protagonists don't evolve their relationship, and the main character stays the same the whole anime without developing her personality. This consists of her having the personality of a glass of water you forgot in the car for some days and you have to drink because you're thirsty; the male protagonist just likes her for no reason at all. Even the background characters seem to be more pleasant to have a relationship with. It is enjoyable to an extent, but it just screams "femcel dream."
I like the idea of an ugly (nonconventional) character, but for it to work, she
...
has to have character development and a good personality instead of just saying yes because she is socially awkward and can't say no to requests; that is not kindness.
A 5/10, enjoyable, and good fast-food anime to binge when bored.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|