Back to PandaRoomster's Profile PandaRoomster's Profile

Wow, what a read this was! It’s one of those series where you read the first few chapters and just know you’re experiencing something special. I think it also carries a great message about self-love and the importance of communication.

All 20 chapters bring something to the table—not a single one feels insignificant. The progress of the main couple is so tastefully slow, yet steady and consistent. Most of their struggles are resolved fairly quickly, but never in a way that feels rushed or cheap. The pacing hits that perfect sweet spot. The side characters also felt very complete, and most of them played crucial roles ... in the story rather than just being background noise.

This beautiful and sweet story is backed by lovely art, with each character having unique features that make them instantly recognizable.

I'm honestly regretting not picking this up sooner. I'd absolutely recommend it to any fan of the genre, and I'll definitely be checking out the author's other work.

10/10 – Masterpiece

This series is as straightforward as it gets. There’s a gag, a very barebones plot, and… that’s about it. It’s cute, it’s light, and it doesn’t try to be anything more than your standard dose of cute girls doing cute things. I didn’t really see anything here that I haven’t already seen elsewhere.

The 18 chapters are super short and fly by in a breeze—it’s an easy read you can finish in one sitting.
So, should you read this? If you’ve got 30 minutes to kill, I don’t see why not. Just don’t go in expecting any big twists or deep storytelling.

6/10 – Fine

This series sits firmly in the average-but-could've-been-great category. It had a solid foundation—a unique setting that really worked—but the short runtime didn’t give it the breathing room it needed. Because of that, it ends up feeling more like an extended one-shot than a fully realized story.

There were so many missed opportunities. A deeper dive into Makino’s backstory could’ve added some real emotional weight, and the side characters definitely had potential that just went unexplored. And as for the ending—it didn’t feel like a true conclusion, more like the story just... stopped.

That said, I still enjoyed my time with it. The art was cute, the vibes ... were nice, and even if the story didn’t hit as hard as it could have, it kept me interested while it lasted. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re in the mood for something short and light.

6/10 – Fine, but could’ve been more.

This series had a lot of potential. It was super cute, packed with fluff, and featured some pretty likeable characters.

The main issue? Most of the story feels kind of pointless. It doesn’t really push the main characters’ relationship forward in any meaningful way. I don’t mind a good tease here and there—an interrupted kiss or a misunderstood confession can be fun. But when the same trick is repeated for half the series, it gets old fast. Each chapter gives the illusion of progress, only to end up back at square one. This also makes the ending feel pretty unfulfilling and shallow.

Another nitpick is that some ... of the characters looked a bit too similar in black and white, which made it hard to tell them apart at times. That aside, the art overall looked quite good and was pleasant to follow.

Despite the flawed storytelling, I’d be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy reading this. The pacing is quick, even if the events don’t always lead anywhere, and I never felt bored. And honestly, I’m a sucker for some good ol’ fluff.

6/10 – Fine.

I started this manga thinking it would just be some light-hearted fluff to read before bed. Instead, I got a pretty unique series—one that isn’t afraid to touch on real societal issues. It doesn’t just drop the characters into some pre-made world where no one bats an eye at a homosexual relationship, and that’s something I don’t see too often.

The early chapters felt a bit repetitive, with Hiroko stuck in denial over and over again. Honestly, you could cut the number of these chapters in half without losing much of the plot. That said, the story picks up towards the end and gets pretty interesting. ... Overall, I’d say I enjoyed it, even if the beginning felt slow.

The art was pleasant to look at, and the character designs were distinct enough that you could recognize everyone at a glance, which is always a plus.


Summary:
This series feels like a breath of fresh air compared to the usual trope of two high school girls in a world where same-sex relationships are treated as completely normal. The story does take its time to get going, though, so you’ll need a bit of patience at first.

7/10 – Good

Being a big fan of the manga, I was really excited for the anime debut of Whisper Me a Love Song. Unfortunately, my experience with it was pretty mixed.


Production:
Let’s get the obvious out of the way—yes, like most people, I was disappointed by the production quality. I’m not usually someone who needs top-tier animation to enjoy a show, but the issues here were hard to ignore. The art often felt raw and unfinished, like I was watching some kind of fan edit. It’s a shame, because the manga is one of the prettiest series I’ve ever read. The long delays in production didn’t help either—understandable, ... sure, but still frustrating.
On the bright side, the voice acting was great. It all felt natural and fit the characters well, which is especially impressive considering some of the cast were newbie voice actresses.

Characters:
The cast is small but very colorful and varied. Unfortunately, with only 12 episodes, there wasn’t enough time to really develop most of them. Even so, they managed to leave an impression, and I enjoyed seeing them come to life.

Story:
Since I already knew the story from the manga, I wasn’t expecting to be blown away, but it was still nice to see it in animated form. That said, 12 episodes just weren’t enough to do it justice. Some parts felt rushed, and a lot of the details were skipped over. Still, I’m glad they managed to cover as much as they did, because let’s be real—after the production issues, I’m not holding my breath for a second season. And hey, at least they didn’t leave us with a cliffhanger!

Soundtrack:
One thing the anime has over the manga is the ability to hear the music. Since this is a music-focused series, that’s a pretty big deal. SS’s songs, though, felt kind of generic to me—nothing special. Laureley, on the other hand, was fantastic. I listen to "Meritocracy" regularly, and hearing the intro to "Wolfish" was the final push I needed to pick up bass guitar myself.


Final Thoughts:
I love this series, and it will always hold a special place in my heart. But the production issues in the anime were just too big to ignore. While I’d recommend the manga in a heartbeat, the anime is probably safe to skip.

5/10 – Average (but only because I’m biased).

Your Lie in April is nothing short of a masterpiece, and I totally understand why this series is so beloved.

Art:
The art didn’t really speak to me personally, but it was consistent throughout and didn’t have any weak moments. I found the use of colour to be a nice touch. I also loved how the piano was animated—the detailed shots of the inside parts were fascinating, and I’m guessing the hand movements were accurate too, though I’m no expert.

Music:
I’m not a musician, so I can’t say what makes one pianist better than another. But the piano music in this anime felt like it truly spoke to ... me. Despite my lack of musical knowledge, I could feel what the pieces were trying to convey (though that is probably to be expected from an anime with such a heavy focus on music...).

Characters:
One of the things I really appreciated was how the story didn’t just focus on the two main characters. Most of the cast felt like they mattered, and I’m glad they got the attention they deserved. There were just enough characters to keep things interesting without making anyone feel forgettable.

Story:
The story was fantastic. The pacing was great, and I have to admit, this show had me losing sleep. I’m not someone who usually binges a series in just a few days, but the pianist in the blue suit had that something that kept me hooked.


Despite my high praise, I'd like to adress a few negatives as well:

Though I just praised the development that most of the characters received, I felt like Tsubaki didn’t get the proper conclusion she deserved. It felt like she was just kind of tossed aside with a shrug, like, “Eh, she’ll be fine.”

I also wasn’t a big fan of the “violence = funny” scenes, which were surprisingly common. Sure, it might have worked once or twice, but it felt way overused. You have this perfectly bittersweet story on your hands—why stain it with goofy, out-of-place moments that don’t fit the tone?


Still, these criticisms aren’t enough to lower my rating. I’d give this series a perfect 10/10.
Thank you, Maty, for the recommendation—I had an amazing time watching it.

I realized very early on that I’m probably not the target demographic for this anime—it seems clearly aimed at p*rn-addicted self-inserts. Since I don’t consider myself part of that group, take my review with a grain of salt.

I have very mixed feelings about this anime, so I’ll break them down into clear points:

Art and Design:
Easily the best part of the series. The character designs are beautiful, and the animation is consistently well-executed. I honestly can’t ask for much more in this department—it’s top-notch.


Characters:
There’s plenty of variety among the characters, but many feel like they exist solely to attract as wide an audience as possible. The ... main character is a pitiful attempt at a relatable self-insert—Oh, he’s actually a reliable guy just pretending to be lazy? That feels like a shallow ploy to make romantically frustrated men think, “Oh, he’s just like me!”

Yuki, in particular, left me baffled. What was her end goal? Did she want to surpass her brother? Did she wish for her brother to be happy with Alya? Or—disturbingly—was she trying to seduce her own brother? Incest is not okay, and it’s easily the most disgusting aspect of this anime. I genuinely worry about the people who enjoy such a trope in a show. Do better.


Plot:
The plotline isn’t particularly groundbreaking. The student council setting ensures that at least something is always happening, but it doesn’t reach very deep. The way the student council is treated with such gravity feels a bit over-the-top, though this might be due to cultural differences and it's definitely not exclusive to only this anime, so I won't take points away for that.

Given that this is supposed to be a romcom, I personally would’ve liked to see more emphasis on the romance. The comedy element works occasionally, but it often feels cheap and doesn’t leave much of an impact in the grand scheme of things.


Fan Service:
I understand that fan service makes money, but I don’t understand the appeal of mixing it into an anime. If I’m bored, I’ll watch an entertaining show full of drama. If I want to see women in underwear, I’ll watch an entirely different type of video. Combining the two feels unnecessary and detracts from the overall experience.

Furthermore, this series takes fan service to uncomfortable extremes. What did the hypnosis scene add to the plot? Nothing! It just made all of the unga-bungas drool because “haha boobie.” This kind of content is exactly why I feel like I’m likely not the target demographic.


Summary:
Despite its many negatives, I can’t say I didn’t enjoy the show at least a little. It does have its charm, I suppose. I’ll stick around for the second season in the hope that some of these issues are addressed. The potential is clearly there.

5/10 – Average

Oh my, this series is almost too sweet for its own good. I won’t spoil anything, but by the time I finished, I was absolutely devastated. The sheer sadness of it all really hit me—the story is incredibly captivating and emotionally gripping.

The main characters complement each other beautifully, making their connection feel genuine and heartfelt. The romance isn’t really there, but it’s not needed in this story—it still manages to be incredibly touching without it.
The art is stunning and the cover of volume 1 is one of my favourites.

Big recommend, but consider yourself warned: you might shed a few tears...

This series takes its time, with a slow pace and not much happening plot-wise. The main characters can be quite awkward, but there’s a certain charm to their interactions that kept me entertained throughout. But it really isn't that deep.

Maybe focusing more on the side characters would have been an interesting direction, as they could have brought some additional depth or variety to the story.

If you’re looking for lots of drama or unexpected plot twists, you’ll probably want to look elsewhere. But if you’re in the mood for something sweet, light, and easy to enjoy without overthinking, this series is a delightful choice.