The reviews don't do justice to this anime.

Sep 25, 2022 8:07 PM

#51

vibininthefields

Offline

Aug 2021

253

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

I think they're tagged preliminary reviews in the system.

yeah and they've been tagged that way for weeks now. these guys just dropped a preliminary review and then up and left.

That's kind of on the viewers too to make decisions after using their critical thinking skills no?

Sep 25, 2022 8:11 PM

#52

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

oataoa said:

Aug1799 said:
Definitely worth watching.
Watch it with an open mind guys, the reviews are crazy in this one.
The reviews on this anime are mostly ppl disappointed with the MC's character development. Yes i agree that the impact is lesser when compared to season 1 which most ppl refer to as the revenge Arc. But rating it 2/3 is just downright stupid and presumptious. And also there's the point that naofumi was actually quite a nice guy as seen in episode 1 before bitch and trash frame him, how long do you expect the author to milk him as a short tempered edgy dude? He had to get back to his old self at some point. To anyone who says that he gets whatever he wants now without having to work for it anymore like before, that's not entirely true since he still goes around as a travelling merchant and doesn't exploit his perks as a hero or anything.

All the reviews keep complaining about deteriorated art style, pacing and the morality of slave crests etc. So the plot gets no credit then? The plot is actually intresting, it goes on building up well albeit the pacing is whack in the first 5-6 episodes the anime still wraps up quite well towards the end.

Honestly i was tired of seeing the spear, bow and sword heroes making a fool of themselves and this season just completely removes them from the scene, which was quite soothing for me. Not to mention they even bring in more detail to Larc, Therese and glass and also give them more screen time.

Even if you take all the negative points it doesn't deserve anything less than a solid 6/7. Don't read the reviews and watch it for yourself. It definitely does justice to it's tags, yes it may be a bit underwhelming when compared to the prequel but whoever went and decided that each and every successive season is supposed to be substantially on par with its predecessors? It's a story and this just another Arc, still much more entertaining than many anime out there.
For me it was a solid 8 though.

Edit: yes it's a long post sorry about that guys.
and also I'm writing this review because many ppl tend to look at discussions more than reviews to judge an anime as far as I've seen.

Don’t mind people reviews too much, most of them are just sad human beings, the anime was a massive hit in japan, and japanese studio don’t care at all about western reviews, that’s why we’ll have a season 3 and probably 4

I’d say humanity is at least made of 50% very angry and overall sad human beings, and that’s the group who speaks the most, normal people just don’t need to be angry all the time or always complain

Keep enjoying the manga and watching the seasons and anime you want, trying to speak to randoms on MAL is pointless, trying to debate with someone here is the same as giving a stick to a random guy and ask him to build a spaceship for mars with it xD, in other words it’s a complete waste of time

You didn’t knew these people 5 minutes ago and you won’t even remember they even existed on earth to begin with tomorrow, so don’t mind anyone here xD

haha,yes you're absolutely right. but my intention is just to get the idea out there for ppl who are considering to drop it after reading the reviews.

for ppl who already watched it and hated it, i don't really care much because they had their reasons to hate it. So no worries i won't waste my time trying to change their opinion or anything.

Sep 25, 2022 8:15 PM

#53

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

yeah and they've been tagged that way for weeks now. these guys just dropped a preliminary review and then up and left.

That's kind of on the viewers too to make decisions after using their critical thinking skills no?

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Sep 25, 2022 8:19 PM

#54

Aruchemist

Offline

May 2021

572

How can a review could do justice to an anime? Rating and people's reviews never matter, what matter the most is your own experience. Only stupid people take them that seriously for consuming anime. There is no metric to "gIvE jUsTiCe". Ironically, you whining about this is even more stupid than what you call these people stupid for rating something low.

If you disagree and dislike with those reviews then go to the reviewers profile and message them instead of whining here, isn't that simpler and more straight forward?

Sep 25, 2022 8:22 PM

#55

CHT13

Offline

May 2022

951

soulguard said:
Season 2 was a Clear 4 For me.
it is really stupid in my sight and it showed me to never be hyped when a sequal comes Out.
when i Read people rate Season 1 a 10??
and Season 2 a 8???/10 i really Wonder how they rate an Anime.

You wonder how people rate anime? Based on their opinions is how. You have one of my all time favorites, full metal panic, rated 5’s across the board and I don’t have an issue with that. It’s your opinion. You have Arifureta season 1 and 2 rated 8 and 7 and I think they’re laughable trash. We’re allowed to have a difference of opinion. One doesn’t invalidate the other.

Sep 25, 2022 8:24 PM

#56

vibininthefields

Offline

Aug 2021

253

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

That's kind of on the viewers too to make decisions after using their critical thinking skills no?

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Reviews fo what they're supposed to do, which is basically give you someone else's opinion. Now your policy is your own, other people may use these reviews to see if there's something more in it to attract them to the source material than what's given in the synopsis to give it a watch. Everyone does things their own way.

Sep 25, 2022 8:33 PM

#57

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Reviews fo what they're supposed to do, which is basically give you someone else's opinion. Now your policy is your own, other people may use these reviews to see if there's something more in it to attract them to the source material than what's given in the synopsis to give it a watch. Everyone does things their own way.

I'm not spreading my policies anywhere.
I'm saying i don't have any use for a review that's from the shallow perspective of someone who couldn't even sit through the whole thing.
If those reviews genuinely help you then good on you, you won't have to sit through anything you might possibly not like.

yup and everyone does things their own way which is completely well and fine.
my intention for creating this discussion was just to put the idea out there for the ppl who might drop after reading those reviews. I wanted to create a discussion which would make ppl consider giving it a chance. This is me doing things my way.

Sep 25, 2022 8:37 PM

#58

CHT13

Offline

May 2022

951

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Reviews fo what they're supposed to do, which is basically give you someone else's opinion. Now your policy is your own, other people may use these reviews to see if there's something more in it to attract them to the source material than what's given in the synopsis to give it a watch. Everyone does things their own way.

Same with the rating system on this site. I know it’s totally flawed but if I’m trying to choose what to watch between 2 shows I’ll sometimes look at the scores and pick one that way.

Sep 25, 2022 8:41 PM

#59

vibininthefields

Offline

Aug 2021

253

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

Mando727 said:
I mean, I think a lot of people are justified in their distaste for this season, but personally, I completely agree with your score.

Season 2 for me was an 8/10, while season 1 was an easy 10/10. So an obvious downgrade and definitely a bit of a disappointment, but that’s not to say that season 2 was bad. Because it was actually still really enjoyable, and I loved it.

But whatever. If people didn’t like it, then there’s not really much that anyone can do about it.

I’m mostly just hoping that season 3 will be better so that this show can gain back some of its popularity.

I agree with the reasons they give for their distaste, but come on was it 2/10 or 3/10 bad. now that's a stretch in my opinion. lmao.

if you check out the episodes watched of those people, they're the ones who had dropped the season after the first three (most of them) and even if I was to rate those episodes, it wouldn't have been anything higher than a 4.

is it not fair to the anime to be judged so soon and so rashly like that? it's not, but most people didn't want to sit through 6 boring episodes for the 6 great ones at the end. They'd left by then.

if they don't want to sit they don't need to. but writing a review without finishing a series would make for a shallow review.

I think they're tagged preliminary reviews in the system.

yeah and they've been tagged that way for weeks now. these guys just dropped a preliminary review and then up and left.

That's kind of on the viewers too to make decisions after using their critical thinking skills no?

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Reviews fo what they're supposed to do, which is basically give you someone else's opinion. Now your policy is your own, other people may use these reviews to see if there's something more in it to attract them to the source material than what's given in the synopsis to give it a watch. Everyone does things their own way.

I'm not spreading my policies anywhere.
I'm saying i don't have any use for a review that's from the shallow perspective of someone who couldn't even sit through the whole thing.
If those reviews genuinely help you then good on you, you won't have to sit through anything you might possibly not like.

yup and everyone does things their own way which is completely well and fine.
my intention for creating this discussion was just to put the idea out there for the ppl who might drop after reading those reviews. I wanted to create a discussion which would make ppl consider giving it a chance. This is me doing things my way.

Fair, I hope it works. (Reposting cause I replied without quoting first)

Sep 25, 2022 8:47 PM

#60

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

eyeofflame said:

Aug1799 said:

Mando727 said:
I mean, I think a lot of people are justified in their distaste for this season, but personally, I completely agree with your score.

Season 2 for me was an 8/10, while season 1 was an easy 10/10. So an obvious downgrade and definitely a bit of a disappointment, but that’s not to say that season 2 was bad. Because it was actually still really enjoyable, and I loved it.

But whatever. If people didn’t like it, then there’s not really much that anyone can do about it.

I’m mostly just hoping that season 3 will be better so that this show can gain back some of its popularity.

I agree with the reasons they give for their distaste, but come on was it 2/10 or 3/10 bad. now that's a stretch in my opinion. lmao.

if you check out the episodes watched of those people, they're the ones who had dropped the season after the first three (most of them) and even if I was to rate those episodes, it wouldn't have been anything higher than a 4.

is it not fair to the anime to be judged so soon and so rashly like that? it's not, but most people didn't want to sit through 6 boring episodes for the 6 great ones at the end. They'd left by then.

if they don't want to sit they don't need to. but writing a review without finishing a series would make for a shallow review.

I think they're tagged preliminary reviews in the system.

yeah and they've been tagged that way for weeks now. these guys just dropped a preliminary review and then up and left.

That's kind of on the viewers too to make decisions after using their critical thinking skills no?

if i watched an anime half way through, and wrote a review on it. would it help you in anyway? would you read it? it would basically just sound like i was complaining about the anime without giving it as much as even a single chance.

I've always believed that..... even the trashiest of anime, the worst ones deserve atleast a single watch. atleast that's what I've always believed.

Reviews fo what they're supposed to do, which is basically give you someone else's opinion. Now your policy is your own, other people may use these reviews to see if there's something more in it to attract them to the source material than what's given in the synopsis to give it a watch. Everyone does things their own way.

I'm not spreading my policies anywhere.
I'm saying i don't have any use for a review that's from the shallow perspective of someone who couldn't even sit through the whole thing.
If those reviews genuinely help you then good on you, you won't have to sit through anything you might possibly not like.

yup and everyone does things their own way which is completely well and fine.
my intention for creating this discussion was just to put the idea out there for the ppl who might drop after reading those reviews. I wanted to create a discussion which would make ppl consider giving it a chance. This is me doing things my way.

Fair, I hope it works. (Reposting cause I replied without quoting first)

thanks, that's nice of you!
You're a sensible person.

Sep 25, 2022 9:48 PM

#61

Saimatsu_Fan

Offline

Sep 2021

1364

Rebelpanda's one is espacially bad, particularly since he's biased he hates S1 for shitty reasons

Sep 25, 2022 10:52 PM

#62

Rammelbips

Offline

Jul 2021

285

Aug1799 said:
Definitely worth watching.
Watch it with an open mind guys, the reviews are crazy in this one.
The reviews on this anime are mostly ppl disappointed with the MC's character development. Yes i agree that the impact is lesser when compared to season 1 which most ppl refer to as the revenge Arc. But rating it 2/3 is just downright stupid and presumptious. And also there's the point that naofumi was actually quite a nice guy as seen in episode 1 before bitch and trash frame him, how long do you expect the author to milk him as a short tempered edgy dude? He had to get back to his old self at some point. To anyone who says that he gets whatever he wants now without having to work for it anymore like before, that's not entirely true since he still goes around as a travelling merchant and doesn't exploit his perks as a hero or anything.

All the reviews keep complaining about deteriorated art style, pacing and the morality of slave crests etc. So the plot gets no credit then? The plot is actually intresting, it goes on building up well albeit the pacing is whack in the first 5-6 episodes the anime still wraps up quite well towards the end.

Honestly i was tired of seeing the spear, bow and sword heroes making a fool of themselves and this season just completely removes them from the scene, which was quite soothing for me. Not to mention they even bring in more detail to Larc, Therese and glass and also give them more screen time.

Even if you take all the negative points it doesn't deserve anything less than a solid 6/7. Don't read the reviews and watch it for yourself. It definitely does justice to it's tags, yes it may be a bit underwhelming when compared to the prequel but whoever went and decided that each and every successive season is supposed to be substantially on par with its predecessors? It's a story and this just another Arc, still much more entertaining than many anime out there.
For me it was a solid 8 though.

Edit: yes it's a long post sorry about that guys.
and also I'm writing this review because many ppl tend to look at discussions more than reviews to judge an anime as far as I've seen.

You say people don't credit the plot, and in my opinion you can't with how shitty the pacing and animation are. I do agree that the plot itself is good, but atleast for me it isn't enjoyable with how bad everything else is.

Sep 25, 2022 11:00 PM

#63

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

Rammelbips said:

Aug1799 said:
Definitely worth watching.
Watch it with an open mind guys, the reviews are crazy in this one.
The reviews on this anime are mostly ppl disappointed with the MC's character development. Yes i agree that the impact is lesser when compared to season 1 which most ppl refer to as the revenge Arc. But rating it 2/3 is just downright stupid and presumptious. And also there's the point that naofumi was actually quite a nice guy as seen in episode 1 before bitch and trash frame him, how long do you expect the author to milk him as a short tempered edgy dude? He had to get back to his old self at some point. To anyone who says that he gets whatever he wants now without having to work for it anymore like before, that's not entirely true since he still goes around as a travelling merchant and doesn't exploit his perks as a hero or anything.

All the reviews keep complaining about deteriorated art style, pacing and the morality of slave crests etc. So the plot gets no credit then? The plot is actually intresting, it goes on building up well albeit the pacing is whack in the first 5-6 episodes the anime still wraps up quite well towards the end.

Honestly i was tired of seeing the spear, bow and sword heroes making a fool of themselves and this season just completely removes them from the scene, which was quite soothing for me. Not to mention they even bring in more detail to Larc, Therese and glass and also give them more screen time.

Even if you take all the negative points it doesn't deserve anything less than a solid 6/7. Don't read the reviews and watch it for yourself. It definitely does justice to it's tags, yes it may be a bit underwhelming when compared to the prequel but whoever went and decided that each and every successive season is supposed to be substantially on par with its predecessors? It's a story and this just another Arc, still much more entertaining than many anime out there.
For me it was a solid 8 though.

Edit: yes it's a long post sorry about that guys.
and also I'm writing this review because many ppl tend to look at discussions more than reviews to judge an anime as far as I've seen.

You say people don't credit the plot, and in my opinion you can't with how shitty the pacing and animation are. I do agree that the plot itself is good, but atleast for me it isn't enjoyable with how bad everything else is.

well if it bothered you so much then there's no helping it. I honestly didn't mind it all too much. I mean there are so many worse ones out there when it comes to execution, that I've gotten immune to it or something.

Sep 25, 2022 11:02 PM

#64

Rammelbips

Offline

Jul 2021

285

Aug1799 said:

Rammelbips said:

Aug1799 said:
Definitely worth watching.
Watch it with an open mind guys, the reviews are crazy in this one.
The reviews on this anime are mostly ppl disappointed with the MC's character development. Yes i agree that the impact is lesser when compared to season 1 which most ppl refer to as the revenge Arc. But rating it 2/3 is just downright stupid and presumptious. And also there's the point that naofumi was actually quite a nice guy as seen in episode 1 before bitch and trash frame him, how long do you expect the author to milk him as a short tempered edgy dude? He had to get back to his old self at some point. To anyone who says that he gets whatever he wants now without having to work for it anymore like before, that's not entirely true since he still goes around as a travelling merchant and doesn't exploit his perks as a hero or anything.

All the reviews keep complaining about deteriorated art style, pacing and the morality of slave crests etc. So the plot gets no credit then? The plot is actually intresting, it goes on building up well albeit the pacing is whack in the first 5-6 episodes the anime still wraps up quite well towards the end.

Honestly i was tired of seeing the spear, bow and sword heroes making a fool of themselves and this season just completely removes them from the scene, which was quite soothing for me. Not to mention they even bring in more detail to Larc, Therese and glass and also give them more screen time.

Even if you take all the negative points it doesn't deserve anything less than a solid 6/7. Don't read the reviews and watch it for yourself. It definitely does justice to it's tags, yes it may be a bit underwhelming when compared to the prequel but whoever went and decided that each and every successive season is supposed to be substantially on par with its predecessors? It's a story and this just another Arc, still much more entertaining than many anime out there.
For me it was a solid 8 though.

Edit: yes it's a long post sorry about that guys.
and also I'm writing this review because many ppl tend to look at discussions more than reviews to judge an anime as far as I've seen.

You say people don't credit the plot, and in my opinion you can't with how shitty the pacing and animation are. I do agree that the plot itself is good, but atleast for me it isn't enjoyable with how bad everything else is.

well if it bothered you so much then there's no helping it. I honestly didn't mind it all too much. I mean there are so many worse ones out there when it comes to execution, that I've gotten immune to it or something.

Yeah, I am probably going to read the light novel, because i do really love shield hero

Sep 25, 2022 11:03 PM

#65

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

Saimatsu_Fan said:
Rebelpanda's one is espacially bad, particularly since he's biased he hates S1 for shitty reasons

see that's one of the major problems imo.
I'm sure many will disagree to what i have to say, but there's no point to writing a review if you're not going to judge in an unbiased manner.

the review would become useless because I'd have no idea whether I'll feel the same way or not.

edit: i just went and checked it out.
Did he really type out all that, like wow this dude is committed, it's like his life mission is to hate on shield hero at this point. lmao. we should give him a position next to bitch and trash, he'd fit right in.
He could've watched an episode of some anime he liked instead of wasting his time typing out that massive pile of emotional vomit.

Aug1799Sep 25, 2022 11:13 PM

Sep 25, 2022 11:03 PM

#66

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

Rammelbips said:

Aug1799 said:

Rammelbips said:

Aug1799 said:
Definitely worth watching.
Watch it with an open mind guys, the reviews are crazy in this one.
The reviews on this anime are mostly ppl disappointed with the MC's character development. Yes i agree that the impact is lesser when compared to season 1 which most ppl refer to as the revenge Arc. But rating it 2/3 is just downright stupid and presumptious. And also there's the point that naofumi was actually quite a nice guy as seen in episode 1 before bitch and trash frame him, how long do you expect the author to milk him as a short tempered edgy dude? He had to get back to his old self at some point. To anyone who says that he gets whatever he wants now without having to work for it anymore like before, that's not entirely true since he still goes around as a travelling merchant and doesn't exploit his perks as a hero or anything.

All the reviews keep complaining about deteriorated art style, pacing and the morality of slave crests etc. So the plot gets no credit then? The plot is actually intresting, it goes on building up well albeit the pacing is whack in the first 5-6 episodes the anime still wraps up quite well towards the end.

Honestly i was tired of seeing the spear, bow and sword heroes making a fool of themselves and this season just completely removes them from the scene, which was quite soothing for me. Not to mention they even bring in more detail to Larc, Therese and glass and also give them more screen time.

Even if you take all the negative points it doesn't deserve anything less than a solid 6/7. Don't read the reviews and watch it for yourself. It definitely does justice to it's tags, yes it may be a bit underwhelming when compared to the prequel but whoever went and decided that each and every successive season is supposed to be substantially on par with its predecessors? It's a story and this just another Arc, still much more entertaining than many anime out there.
For me it was a solid 8 though.

Edit: yes it's a long post sorry about that guys.
and also I'm writing this review because many ppl tend to look at discussions more than reviews to judge an anime as far as I've seen.

You say people don't credit the plot, and in my opinion you can't with how shitty the pacing and animation are. I do agree that the plot itself is good, but atleast for me it isn't enjoyable with how bad everything else is.

well if it bothered you so much then there's no helping it. I honestly didn't mind it all too much. I mean there are so many worse ones out there when it comes to execution, that I've gotten immune to it or something.

Yeah, I am probably going to read the light novel, because i do really love shield hero

source always >>> than the adaptations

that's an irrefutable truth
happy reading :)

Sep 25, 2022 11:17 PM

#67

Saimatsu_Fan

Offline

Sep 2021

1364

Aug1799 said:

Saimatsu_Fan said:
Rebelpanda's one is espacially bad, particularly since he's biased he hates S1 for shitty reasons

see that's one of the major problems imo.
I'm sure many will disagree to what i have to say, but there's no point to writing a review if you're not going to judge in an unbiased manner.

the review would become useless because I'd have no idea whether I'll feel the same way or not.

edit: i just went and checked it out.
Did he really type out all that, like wow this dude is committed, it's like his life mission is to hate on shield hero at this point. lmao. we should give him a position next to bitch and trash, he'd fit right in.
He could've watched an episode of some anime he liked instead of wasting his time typing out that massive pile of emotional vomit.

I mean what did you expect from an SJW feminist, I'm not surprised that his reasons are shit

Also rebelpanda has nothing on bis friend Moblack in how much he hates the series

Sep 25, 2022 11:28 PM

#68

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

Saimatsu_Fan said:

Aug1799 said:

see that's one of the major problems imo.
I'm sure many will disagree to what i have to say, but there's no point to writing a review if you're not going to judge in an unbiased manner.

the review would become useless because I'd have no idea whether I'll feel the same way or not.

edit: i just went and checked it out.
Did he really type out all that, like wow this dude is committed, it's like his life mission is to hate on shield hero at this point. lmao. we should give him a position next to bitch and trash, he'd fit right in.
He could've watched an episode of some anime he liked instead of wasting his time typing out that massive pile of emotional vomit.

I mean what did you expect from an SJW feminist, I'm not surprised that his reasons are shit

Also rebelpanda has nothing on bis friend Moblack in how much he hates the series

wow you really went deep down that rabbit hole huh. XD
why would you torture yourself? don't read them.

Sep 25, 2022 11:42 PM

#69

Saimatsu_Fan

Offline

Sep 2021

1364

Aug1799 said:

Saimatsu_Fan said:

I mean what did you expect from an SJW feminist, I'm not surprised that his reasons are shit

Also rebelpanda has nothing on bis friend Moblack in how much he hates the series

wow you really went deep down that rabbit hole huh. XD
why would you torture yourself? don't read them.

I don't lol, i just know about them

Sep 25, 2022 11:56 PM

#70

AlexPlayer

Offline

May 2017

429

I read the manga after season 1 and fucking hated the turtle arc but I still gave the anime a chance. It was still bad, but better than the manga imo.

Most MAL reviews are ass anyways.

Sep 26, 2022 3:12 AM

#71

soulguard

Offline

May 2021

276

CHT13 said:

soulguard said:
Season 2 was a Clear 4 For me.
it is really stupid in my sight and it showed me to never be hyped when a sequal comes Out.
when i Read people rate Season 1 a 10??
and Season 2 a 8???/10 i really Wonder how they rate an Anime.

You wonder how people rate anime? Based on their opinions is how. You have one of my all time favorites, full metal panic, rated 5’s across the board and I don’t have an issue with that. It’s your opinion. You have Arifureta season 1 and 2 rated 8 and 7 and I think they’re laughable trash. We’re allowed to have a difference of opinion. One doesn’t invalidate the other.

Right again,sorry m8 ^^

Sep 26, 2022 4:33 AM

#72

bezardo

Offline

Feb 2021

553

didn't read any but that green haired bitch was soooo annoying i liked the show where raph get a legend sword and mirror collabs . each season they are showing a bitch who simpin for a hero

Sep 26, 2022 9:58 AM

#73

Som3one_

Offline

Mar 2022

6

This season was legit 3/10 and hard to watch. No idea how it has 6.5+ rating

Sep 26, 2022 11:59 AM

#74

Pietru

Offline

Dec 2012

3144

Didn't read but the second season was absolute dogwater compared to the first season I'm sorry; I actually fell asleep and slept for 6 hrs while watching this season

"Only one with the courage
to shoulder the burden
of their own fate can
be called a hero.."

Sep 26, 2022 4:32 PM

#75

MegaStride

Offline

Feb 2017

6006

This season was even worse than the first one and that says something.

Sep 26, 2022 6:06 PM

#76

LoneUlven

Offline

Jun 2022

7

As a lover of TnY I can tell you that the main problem was how they changed the story. The anime is an adaptation from the light novel series, and while it follows them in a certain way, more of the content was original, thay changed a loooot of things. This season was supposed to adapt from volume 5 to 9 of the LN but they horribly rushed it. This is the main reason of the low note.

A lot of people (including me) was expecting epic fights to happen as in the LN, but they just didn't were there. Like when Naofumi has to hold the turtle at a low magic ground for 1 hour just with Ost and Filo, or the time when Naofumi almost sacrificed himself to protect everyone from Kyo's weapons.

I have to say, the first season had original material as well, but at a way lower rate than the second one. So it's kinda obvios, if you follow the LN and watch the anime due to them, this season was a disappointment since it ruins a loot of the story. If you don't follow the original story, then this one will be okay. That's basically pretty much the reason in most cases

There were changes in the characters that were not supposed to happen at this point, like Naofumi personality. He becomes like that way further into the story. I have to admit I like the changes they did to Rishia, I hate her in the LN, at least in this point of the story, due to her constant and annoying "fueeeeh"

LoneUlvenOct 18, 2022 1:15 AM

There couldn’t be a god. I wouldn’t allow it! If any such god existed and allowed this to happen...

I would never forgive them. I’d kill them, whatever it took

Sep 26, 2022 6:35 PM

#77

kur0hagane

Offline

Sep 2022

39

do people actually pay any attention to anime reviews? i don't at all and i don't think anybody should pay those any mind. i jump into any anime/manga that looks interesting.

Peace at all costs.

Sep 27, 2022 12:55 AM

#78

Roevhaal

Tail On!

Offline

Aug 2018

2261

Aug1799 said:

Mando727 said:
I mean, I think a lot of people are justified in their distaste for this season, but personally, I completely agree with your score.

Season 2 for me was an 8/10, while season 1 was an easy 10/10. So an obvious downgrade and definitely a bit of a disappointment, but that’s not to say that season 2 was bad. Because it was actually still really enjoyable, and I loved it.

But whatever. If people didn’t like it, then there’s not really much that anyone can do about it.

I’m mostly just hoping that season 3 will be better so that this show can gain back some of its popularity.

I agree with the reasons they give for their distaste, but come on was it 2/10 or 3/10 bad. now that's a stretch in my opinion. lmao.

Okay so you're fine with their reasoning but because they interpret the numbers differently than you do you felt the need to make this thread to vent?

Sep 27, 2022 1:01 AM

#79

Aug1799

Offline

Jan 2022

284

Roevhaal said:

Aug1799 said:

I agree with the reasons they give for their distaste, but come on was it 2/10 or 3/10 bad. now that's a stretch in my opinion. lmao.

Okay so you're fine with their reasoning but because they interpret the numbers differently than you do you felt the need to make this thread to vent?

i didn't make it to vent though. I've clearly stated my intentions in the last line.

also throughout my post I've just spoken about the anime and asked PPL to give it a chance i haven't criticised anyone's reviews, if you consider calling the reviews as stupid and presumptious for rating the anime without even finishing it through, then yeah i still stand by that statement.

a review based off of the initial episodes is just shallow to me.

Sep 27, 2022 3:24 AM

#80

aLotQuestion_

Offline

Dec 2014

2661

Likers gonna like and haters gonna hate.
Just like OP, he like the series and everyone else must agree with him and also like the series.
Nuff said.

Signature removed. Check your inbox

Sep 27, 2022 3:56 AM

#81

Seygneur

Offline

Jul 2019

816

The descriptive text of the score is pretty fitting in my opinion. It was fine. Not great, not terrible. More TnY, new settings, a new world and some further expansion of the universe. Nothing groundbreaking in any other department.

Considering the awkward pacing of the source material for an anime, I think they actually salvaged what would have been dead average or bellow average in a worst case scenario.

Sep 27, 2022 6:36 AM

#82

aka_mini96

Offline

May 2021

74

I agree with all the points u make. That's also why I stopped really caring about what others thinks regarding a specific anime and I just enjoy it for myself (bc people will always have something to say or they just go with the crowd)

Sep 27, 2022 1:38 PM

#83

DyingLytes

Offline

Jan 2021

129

Well at a fundamental level I couldn’t wait for you to come clear the cupboards But now you’re going to leave with nothing but a sign Another evening I’ll be sitting reading in between your lines Because I miss you all the time So, get away Another way to feel what you didn’t want yourself to know And let yourself go You know you didn’t lose your self-control Let’s start at the rainbow Turn away Another way to be where you didn’t want yourself to go Let yourself go Is that a compromise So what do you wanna do, what’s your point-of-view? There’s a party screaming, do you wanna go? A handshake with you, what’s your point-of-view? I’m on top of you, I don’t wanna go ‘Cause I really wanna stay at your house And I hopе this works out But you know how much you broke me apart I’m done with you, I’m ignoring you I don’t wanna know And I’m awarе that you were lying in the gutter ‘Cause I did everything to be there by your side-ide So when you tell me I’m the reason I just can’t believe the lies And why do I so want to call you (Call you, call you, call you) So what do you wanna do, what’s your point-of-view? There’s a party screaming, do you wanna go? A handshake with you, what’s your point-of-view? I’m on top of you, I don’t wanna go ‘Cause I really wanna stay at your house And I hope this works out But you know how much you broke me apart I’m done with you, I’m ignoring you I don’t wanna know You Oh-oh oh-oh-oh I don’t know why I’m no-one So, get away Another way to feel what you didn’t want yourself to know And let yourself go You know you didn’t lose your self-control Let’s start at the rainbow Turn away Another way to be where you didn’t want yourself to go Let yourself go Is that a compromise So what do you wanna do, what’s your point-of-view There’s a party screaming, do you wanna go? A handshake with you, what’s your point-of-view? I’m on top of you, I don’t wanna go ‘Cause I really wanna stay at your house And I hope this works out But you know how much you broke me apart I’m done with you, I’m ignoring you I don’t wanna know

Sep 28, 2022 12:12 AM

#84

_spoon_

Offline

Jul 2021

3934

Most anime reviews in general are not reliable

Sep 28, 2022 6:58 AM

#85

Twauma

Offline

Oct 2021

78

TBH it was really boring and I think it deserves max 5/10

Sep 28, 2022 10:55 AM

#86

Zoushu

Offline

Sep 2015

680

This was the first time I gave up on a season 2 right at the first episode lol. Will continue reading the manga though.

can dis sig fit

Oct 28, 2022 8:25 PM

#87

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

558999

Pretty sure what I read awhile back that even the person who wrote the manga even said this arc is their worse one and they didn't like it. People don't have to like what you like, you don't have to like their opinion and they don't have to like yours. Honestly even the first season wasn't good, had some good moments but it's just a harem which is meh

Oct 29, 2022 11:17 PM

#88

Co1d

Offline

Feb 2022

87

It was bad, season 2 deserves the rating.

Oct 30, 2022 5:46 AM

#89

SnowHelation

Offline

Jun 2021

174

Yea I pretty much agree with the things you said. I was so happy that we didn’t get to see the three stooges show their lack luster skills this season. I’m also one of the few who liked the turtle arc, but the episodes leading to the end of the season were definitely great. It ended on a good note and I’m excited for season 3.

Nov 4, 2022 5:06 PM

#90

AshenChivalier

Offline

Jan 2017

135

This season sucked compared to season 1 and that's that
Season 1 8/10
Season 2 4/10

Nov 9, 2022 5:16 PM

#91

smallwitchy

Offline

Feb 2020

11

Brother. This was by far the most disappointing sequel I have ever experienced. A total let down

Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Stark700 - Apr 13, 2022	141	by karpentiel »» Feb 1, 2:48 PM
Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) Stark700 - Jun 29, 2022	247	by GTR_FTL »» Jan 26, 7:08 PM
Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) Stark700 - Jun 22, 2022	240	by ElDoRado1239 »» Jan 21, 5:55 PM
Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Stark700 - Apr 6, 2022	297	by Lum_moroboshi »» Nov 18, 2025 1:17 PM
» Tbh Just SKIP the Turtle Arc Br3dWinn3rs - Jun 25, 2022	38	by PirateHasan »» Oct 3, 2025 3:49 AM

The reviews don't do justice to this anime.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari Season 2 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» Tbh Just SKIP the Turtle Arc

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters